Criminal Defense Lawyers

Nassau County Employment Immigration Lawyers

You graduated with a master’s degree in computer science from an American university. Your employer offered you a job and said they’d sponsor your H-1B visa. You registered for the lottery, waited anxiously, and then got the news: not selected. Neither were 330,000 other people who registered that year. Your OPT expires in four months, and you have no idea what to do next.

This is the lottery reality that defines H-1B immigration in America. With approximately 442,000 people competing for about 85,000 visas, the math is brutal: roughly three out of four applicants won’t get selected. No matter how qualified you are, no matter how much your employer wants you, no matter how perfect the job fit – the lottery doesn’t care. It’s random selection, and most people lose.

This article explains how the H-1B lottery actually works, what your real odds are, what happens when you’re not selected, what alternative paths exist, and how to strategically plan for the possibility that you won’t win the lottery this year – or next year, or the year after. Most H-1B guides focus on how to apply. This one focuses on what to do when the lottery says no.

Heres the uncomfortable truth most immigration guides wont tell you: hoping to get selected is not a strategy. With 26% odds in a good year, most people need backup plans. Understanding what happens when you dont win – and having alternatives ready before rejection arrives – is what seperates people who stay in America from people who have to leave.

How the H-1B Lottery Works

The H-1B visa has an annual cap of 85,000 visas: 65,000 for workers with bachelors degrees and an additonal 20,000 for workers with U.S. masters degrees or higher. Because demand far exceeds supply, USCIS uses a lottery to allocate who gets to apply.

The process works like this:

Registration period: In early March, employers register there prospective H-1B workers through an online system. Each registration costs $215 (plus additional fees). The employer provides basic information about the job and the worker.

Lottery selection: USCIS randomly selects enough registrations to meet the annual cap. Since not all selected registrations result in approved petitions, they select more then 85,000 to account for withdrawals and denials.

Notification: Around late March, employers and workers recieve notification of weather they were selected. If selected, the employer can file a full H-1B petition. If not selected, the worker is out of the lottery for that fiscal year.

Filing window: Selected registrations have a limited window (typically April 1 through June 30) to file complete H-1B petitions. Missing the deadline means loosing the selection.

Since 2024, USCIS uses a beneficiary-centric selection system. This means each worker can only have one entry in the lottery, regardless of how many employers register them. Previously, having multiple employers register for the same person increased there odds – that loophole is now closed.

The Real Odds – What the Numbers Actually Mean

For fiscal year 2025, approximately 442,000 unique beneficiaries registered for the H-1B lottery. USCIS selected about 127,624 over two rounds – a combined selection rate of roughly 29%. That means 71% of registrants were not selected.

Heres how the odds break down:

Bachelors degree holders: Approximately 25-26% chance of selection in the regular cap pool.

U.S. masters degree holders: Approximately 46% cumulative chance when considering both the advanced degree pool and the regular cap pool. Masters holders get entered in the 20,000 advanced degree pool first. If not selected there, there automaticly entered in the regular 65,000 pool – giving them two chances.

But even with two chances, most masters graduates arent selected. And for bachelors holders, three out of four will recieve rejection notices.

The lottery dosnt consider your qualifications. A brilliant PhD from MIT has the same statistical chance as any other registrant with equivalent education level. Merit dosnt matter in random selection – only luck.

What Happens When Your Not Selected

Rejection notification typically comes in late March or early April. Your employer recieves notice that your registration was not selected. Now what?

Your employment authorization continues – for now. Not being selected in the H-1B lottery dosnt immediately affect your current status. If your on OPT, you remain on OPT until it expires. The lottery rejection itself dosnt change anything immediatly.

But your clock is ticking. Most people in the H-1B lottery are on post-completion OPT, which gives 12 months of work authorization after graduation. If your OPT is expiring soon and you didnt get selected, you need alternative status before it runs out.

You can try again next year. Theres no limit to how many years you can enter the lottery. Some people try three, four, even five years before getting selected (or giving up). But each year requires maintaining valid status – you cant enter the lottery if your already out of status.

Your employer may not wait. Companies investing in H-1B sponsorship want workers who can stay long-term. After multiple lottery rejections, some employers lose patience and move on to other candidates. The uncertainty cuts both ways.

STEM OPT – The Bridge Strategy

If you graduated with a STEM degree (science, technology, engineering, or mathematics) from an accredited U.S. university, you may be eligable for a 24-month STEM OPT extension. This gives you 36 months of total post-completion work authorization instead of just 12.

STEM OPT is critical for lottery planning because it gives you more chances. With 36 months of work authorization, you can enter the H-1B lottery up to three times before your OPT expires. With only 12 months of regular OPT, you might only get one chance.

STEM OPT requirements:

• Degree in a STEM field on the approved list
• Job directly related to your STEM degree
• Employer enrolled in E-Verify
• Formal training plan (Form I-983) with employer
• Application filed before initial OPT expires

The STEM extension isnt automatic. You must apply, and the job must be substantively related to your degree. An engineering graduate working in engineering qualifies. An engineering graduate working in sales probably dosnt.

Apply for STEM OPT early. Processing times can be several months. If your initial OPT expires while your STEM extension is pending, you may have a gap in work authorization. File early to avoid this problem.

Cap-Exempt Alternatives – Avoiding the Lottery Entirely

Not all H-1B visas are subject to the annual cap. Certain employers can sponsor H-1B workers without going through the lottery at all. Finding a cap-exempt employer might be the most reliable path to H-1B status.

Universities and higher education institutions: H-1B workers at colleges and universities are cap-exempt. If you can get a job at a university – even in a non-teaching role like IT or administration – you avoid the lottery completly.

Nonprofit research organizations: Nonprofit organizations primarily engaged in research are cap-exempt. This includes think tanks, research institutes, and similar organizations.

Nonprofit entities affiliated with higher education: Nonprofits related to or affiliated with institutions of higher education may be cap-exempt. Medical centers associated with universities often qualify.

Government research organizations: Some government research facilities are cap-exempt.

Cap-exempt status belongs to the employer, not the position. Working at Harvard’s IT department? Cap-exempt. Working at a private tech company? Subject to the cap, regardless of how cutting-edge there work is.

One strategic approach: start at a cap-exempt employer, get your H-1B, then transfer to a cap-subject employer later. Once you have H-1B status, transferring to a new employer dosnt require going through the lottery again.

Other Visa Alternatives

H-1B isnt the only path to work authorization. Other visa categories may fit your situation.

O-1 visa (Extraordinary Ability): For individuals with extraordinary ability in sciences, arts, education, business, or athletics. No lottery, no annual cap. The standard is high – you need to demonstrate sustained national or international acclaim. But for truly exceptional professionals, O-1 is more reliable then H-1B.

L-1 visa (Intracompany Transferee): For employees transferring from a foreign office to a U.S. office of the same company. Requires one year of employment abroad first. If your company has international offices, you might work abroad temporarily, then transfer to the U.S. on L-1 without needing H-1B.

TN visa (NAFTA Professionals): For Canadian and Mexican citizens in certain professional occupations. No lottery, no cap, renewable indefinately. If you qualify, TN is far simpler then H-1B.

E-2 Treaty Investor: If you have capital to invest in a U.S. business, E-2 provides work authorization. Requires substantial investment and a treaty relationship between the U.S. and your country.

Day 1 CPT (Curricular Practical Training): Some universities allow students to work full-time under CPT from day one of there program while pursuing a new degree. This is controversial and carries risks, but some people use it to maintain status while waiting for H-1B lottery selections.

Strategic Planning for Multiple Attempts

If your serious about getting an H-1B, plan for multiple lottery attempts. Treating each year as all-or-nothing is emotionally and practicaly foolish.

Year 1: Your in the lottery for the first time, probably on initial OPT. If selected, great. If not, apply for STEM OPT extension immediately (if eligable).

Year 2: Your on STEM OPT, enter the lottery again. Selection rate still ~26%. If not selected, you have time remaining on STEM OPT.

Year 3: Third lottery attempt while STEM OPT remains valid. This is often the last chance before status expires. If not selected, you need alternative plans ready.

Backup at every stage: Throughout this process, identify cap-exempt employers you could work for. Research O-1 qualifications. Consider weather L-1 through international assignment is possible. Have multiple paths ready, not just hope.

Employers should understand this timeline to. Smart employers who value foreign workers support backup planning rather then assuming the lottery will work out.

Specialty Occupation Requirements

Even if you win the lottery, your H-1B petition can still be denied if the job dosnt qualify as a specialty occupation. Understanding these requirements helps you and your employer structure the position correctly.

A specialty occupation must meet one of these criteria:

• Bachelors degree or higher is the normal minimum entry requirement for the position
• The degree requirement is common to the industry for parallel positions
• The employer normally requires a degree for this specific position
• The job duties are so specialized and complex that a degree is normaly required

The degree must be directly related to the job. A position requiring “any bachelors degree” dosnt qualify – the degree field must specifically relate to the job duties. Software developer requiring a computer science degree? Specialty occupation. Marketing coordinator requiring any bachelors? Probably not.

USCIS has become stricter about specialty occupation determinations. Jobs that previously qualified sometimes face challenges now. Having strong documentation connecting the degree requirement to the actual job duties is essential.

What Happens After Selection

Being selected in the lottery isnt the end – its the beginning of the petition process. Selection just means you can file a complete H-1B petition. USCIS still has to approve it.

Petition filing: Your employer must file Form I-129 with supporting documentation within the filing window (typically April 1 – June 30). This includes the Labor Condition Application (LCA), evidence of the job requirements, evidence of your qualifications, and various fees.

USCIS review: USCIS adjudicates the petition. They may approve it, deny it, or issue a Request for Evidence (RFE) asking for more documentation. Premium processing ($2,805) gets decisions in 15 business days. Regular processing takes several months.

RFEs are common: Requests for evidence arent denials – there requests for clarification or additional proof. Responding promptly and thoroughly usually resolves them. Common RFE topics include specialty occupation justification and beneficiary qualifications.

Approval: If approved, you recieve H-1B status beginning October 1 (the start of the federal fiscal year). If your already in the U.S. on OPT, your status automaticly changes to H-1B on October 1. Your OPT remains valid until then under the “cap gap” extension.

Denial: If denied, you lose that lottery selection. You can try again in future years, but this year’s opportunity is gone. Having STEM OPT remaining gives you time to try again.

The Employer Perspective

Employers sponsoring H-1B workers face there own challenges with the lottery system. Understanding there perspective helps you be a better candidate.

Cost and uncertainty: H-1B sponsorship costs thousands of dollars in filing fees, legal fees, and administrative time. When 74% of lottery registrations dont get selected, employers invest resources with no guarentee of return.

Business planning difficulties: Companies cant reliably plan there workforce when key hires depend on random lottery selection. A team might desperatly need someone who dosnt get selected, while the lottery picks someone for a less critical role.

Retention concerns: After multiple lottery rejections, will the worker leave for a cap-exempt employer or return to there home country? Employers worry about investing in someone who may not be able to stay.

Being proactive about backup plans and demonstrating commitment to finding solutions makes you more attractive to employers navigating these uncertainties.

The Cap Gap Extension

If you win the lottery while on OPT, you dont have to worry about your OPT expiring before October 1 (when H-1B status begins). The “cap gap” provision automaticly extends your OPT and work authorization until your H-1B kicks in.

The cap gap extension applies if:

• Your on F-1 status with OPT employment authorization
• Your H-1B petition was timely filed for the October 1 start date
• Your OPT would otherwise expire between April 1 and September 30

With cap gap, your OPT is automaticly extended through September 30. You can continue working for your employer during this period. Once October 1 arrives and your H-1B is approved, your status transitions seamlessly.

But heres the risk: if your H-1B petition is denied during the cap gap period, your OPT extension terminates. You’d have limited time to either leave the country or find another way to maintain status. Cap gap protects you while the petition is pending, not forever.

H-1B Timing and Planning Calendar

H-1B follows a predictable annual calendar. Understanding the timeline helps you plan ahead.

October – December (Prior Year): Start conversations with your employer about H-1B sponsorship for the upcoming fiscal year. Ensure they understand the process, costs, and timeline.

January – February: Employer works with immigration attorneys to prepare the Labor Condition Application (LCA) and gather documentation. The LCA must be certified before registration opens.

Early March: H-1B registration period opens. Employers submit registrations for workers they want to sponsor. This is just registration – not the full petition.

Late March: Lottery selection occurs. USCIS notifies employers weather there registrations were selected.

April 1 – June 30: Selected registrations can file complete H-1B petitions. Missing this window wastes the selection.

April – September: USCIS adjudicates petitions. Approvals, denials, and RFEs come during this period.

October 1: H-1B status begins for approved petitions. Workers transition from OPT to H-1B.

For workers on OPT, this means your likely entering the lottery in your final months of initial OPT (if graduating in May) or during STEM OPT (if you filed for the extension). Understanding the cap season timeline helps you coordinate your status strategy.

Future Changes and Policy Uncertainty

H-1B rules change regularlly. Policy shifts can make the lottery easier, harder, or diffrent in ways that affect your planning.

Recent and proposed changes include:

Beneficiary-centric selection (2024): The shift to one lottery entry per person (rather then per registration) reduced gaming but didnt significently change overall odds for most applicants.

Weighted lottery proposal: DHS has proposed moving from random selection to a weighted system favoring higher-wage positions. If implemented, this would dramaticly change who gets selected – benefiting higher-paid workers and disadvantaging entry-level positions.

Specialty occupation tightening: USCIS has become stricter about what qualifies as a specialty occupation. Positions that qualified in 2015 might face challenges today.

Fee increases: Filing fees have increased significently and may continue rising. This affects employer willingness to sponsor.

Policy uncertainty makes long-term planning harder. What’s true this year may not be true next year. Staying informed about regulatory changes and adjusting your strategy accordingly is part of successful H-1B planning.

Common Mistakes in H-1B Planning

People make predictable mistakes when planning for H-1B. Avoiding these improves your chances of staying in the U.S. long-term.

Assuming youll get selected. With 26% odds, assumption is foolish. Plan for rejection from the start.

Not applying for STEM OPT early enough. Processing delays can create gaps in work authorization. Apply months before your initial OPT expires, not weeks.

Ignoring cap-exempt options. University jobs arent just for academics. IT, finance, HR, administration – universities hire for everything. A cap-exempt H-1B is worth considering even if the salary is lower.

Waiting until after rejection to find alternatives. By the time you learn your not selected, your OPT might be expiring soon. Research alternatives before the lottery, not after.

Not maintaining status. You cant enter future lotteries if your out of status. Maintaining valid authorization is essential for multiple attempts.

Lottery planning should start before graduation, not after. The choices you make about degrees, employers, and timing affect your odds for years.

Nassau County Employment Immigration Lawyers

Employment immigration – especialy H-1B – involves complex planning across multiple years and contingencies. Having legal guidance helps you understand your options and structure your approach strategicly.

Look for attorneys who handle H-1B cases regularly and understand both the lottery system and the alternatives. Ask about there experience with STEM OPT, cap-exempt employers, and O-1 visas. A good employment immigration attorney helps you plan for multiple scenarios, not just hope for lottery success.

The lottery reality is harsh but not hopeless. Understanding the odds, planning for multiple attempts, building backup options, and maintaining status throughout gives you the best chance of achieving your employment immigration goals – even when the lottery says no.