Criminal Defense Lawyers

ATF Raided My Gun Store This Morning

ATF Raided My Gun Store This Morning – What Happens Now

You got to your store this morning and federal agents were waiting. ATF. Badges. A van. People with clipboards going through your inventory. Your first instinct is probably panic – “I’m being raided.” But before you spiral, you need to understand something critical: there’s a massive difference between what’s actually happening and what you think is happening. The distinction will determine whether you lose your business, face federal charges, or walk away with nothing more than a warning letter.

Welcome to Spodek Law Group. We handle ATF matters for Federal Firearms Licensees regularly. The first thing you need to know is this: ATF has two completely separate divisions that interact with gun dealers, and confusing them is the worst mistake you can make. Industry Operations Investigators – the people doing compliance inspections – don’t carry guns and can’t arrest you. ATF Special Agents – the people doing criminal investigations – carry firearms and absolutely can arrest you. Knowing which group just walked into your store changes everything about how you respond.

If it’s an IOI conducting a compliance inspection, you’re facing a regulatory process that could end in a warning letter, a warning conference, or license revocation. If it’s Special Agents conducting a criminal investigation, you may be facing federal charges for firearms trafficking, straw purchases, or other serious crimes. In the chaos of federal agents showing up at your business, most dealers don’t ask which division is present. They assume the worst and make panicked decisions that hurt them in either scenario.

How ATF Compliance Inspections Actually Work

Heres what most gun dealers dont understand about ATF inspections. The agency employs over 700 Industry Operations Investigators nationwide who inspect the 78,000+ FFLs across the country. There mission is supposedly educational – to ensure compliance with federal firearms regulations. But in fiscal year 2023, those “educational” visits resulted in 170 license revocations. Thats nearly double the revocations from the previous year.

The inspections are generally unannounced. They happen during business hours. IOIs can legally inspect your inventory, your records, your storage locations – anything related to your FFL. ATF is limited to one warrantless compliance inspection per twelve-month period. However – and this is critical – they can return at any time for trace requests related to criminal investigations. If a gun you sold ends up at a crime scene, the one-inspection-per-year limitation dosent apply.

In fiscal year 2023, ATF inspected 8,689 FFLs. That sounds like alot untill you realize it represents only 6.6% of all licensed dealers. The average FFL used to get inspected once every five to seven years. Some went much longer – an audit found that 2,200 active FFLs hadnt been inspected in over twelve years. But the inspection rate is increasing, particularly for dealers with prior violations or those connected to crime gun traces.

Heres the number that should concern you: 18% of all inspections in FY2023 found violations. If they come to your store, the odds are nearly one in five that they find something wrong. And under the enhanced enforcement policies of recent years, what would of been a warning letter five years ago might now be grounds for revocation.

The Five Violations That Trigger Automatic Revocation

Not all violations are equal. ATF has identified five specific violations that it considers serious enough to warrant immediate revocation proceedings when willfully committed. If an IOI finds any of these during your inspection, your in serious trouble:

1. Transferring a firearm to a prohibited person. This includes knowing sales to felons, domestic abusers, drug users, and others banned from possessing firearms. Even if you ran a background check and it came back clean, if ATF can show you had reason to know the buyer was prohibited, your facing revocation.

2. Failing to run a required background check. Every transfer to a non-licensee requires a NICS check. Miss one, and if ATF characterizes it as willful, your done.

3. Falsifying records. This includes errors on Form 4473, incorrect entries in your A&D book, backdating transactions, or any other documentation issues that ATF interprets as intentional deception.

4. Failing to respond to an ATF tracing request. When a crime gun gets traced back to your store, ATF sends a trace request. Fail to respond – or respond late or incompletely – and you’ve committed a revocable violation.

5. Refusing to permit ATF to conduct an inspection. This one is absolute. If you refuse entry to IOIs conducting a lawful inspection, your license is gone. Period. No second chances.

Heres the uncomfortable truth: almost every FFL has some level of paperwork violation. Missing serial numbers. Incomplete addresses. Entries that dont match across documents. The question isnt wheather you have violations – you probly do. The question is wheather ATF chooses to characterize those violations as “willful.”

The “Willfulness” Trap

OK so this is were it gets truly frightening for gun dealers. Under federal law, ATF cannot revoke your license unless they prove violations were “willful.” That sounds protective. It isnt.

ATF has developed an interpretation of “willfulness” that dosent require criminal intent. They argue that when you received your FFL, you received the Federal Firearms Regulations Reference Guide. That guide explains all the rules. Therefore, any violation of those rules must be willful – becuase you had the guide, you knew the rules, and you chose to violate them.

Think about what that means. You made an honest mistake on a Form 4473 – transposed two digits in a serial number, maybe. ATF can argue that mistake was “willful” becuase you received a manual twenty years ago that explained how to fill out the form correctly. The fact that you didnt intend to violate the rules dosent matter. The fact that you received a document explaining the rules is enough.

This interpretation was formalized in ATF Order 5370.1E in January 2022. Under that guidance, the specified “zero tolerance” violations were treated as inherently willful. No history of prior violations required. No pattern needed. One violation, characterized as willful, and your license could be revoked.

The order was technically revoked in August 2024 following litigation. But the mindset hasnt changed. Revocation rates remain elevated. IOIs trained under that policy are still conducting inspections. And the “willfulness” interpretation that developed during that period still influences how cases are processed.

The Crime Gun Trace Connection

Heres something that keeps gun dealers up at night. When a firearm is recovered at a crime scene – any crime scene, anywhere in the country – it gets traced. ATF’s eTrace system connects that gun to the original sale within days. And if that trace leads back to your shop, expect a visit.

Crime gun traces trigger what ATF calls “priority inspections.” These happen within 60 to 90 days of the trace. They are not friendly. The IOI showing up at your door isnt there for routine education – there looking for a pattern that explains why guns you sold keep showing up in crimes.

It dosent matter that you followed all the rules on the original sale. It dosent matter that the buyer passed a background check. If guns from your shop are showing up at crime scenes, ATF wants to know why. And there going to go through your records looking for any indication that you knew or should of known something was wrong.

Heres the hidden connection most dealers miss. Buying patterns trigger scrutiny. If someone buys two or more handguns within five consecutive business days, you must file a Multiple Purchase Report with ATF. If someone buys ten or more firearms in thirty days, an investigation is essentially guaranteed. But even patterns that dont trigger mandatory reporting can draw attention. A customer who buys multiple firearms and then those firearms show up at crime scenes within months? ATF may accuse you of knowingly enabling straw purchases – even if every individual sale was technically compliant.

And you wont know any of this is happening. Crime gun traces are processed without notifying the original dealer. The first you might hear about it is when an IOI shows up for a “priority inspection” and starts asking pointed questions about specific transactions from three years ago.

The Enforcement Ladder

ATF enforcement follows a predictable ladder. Understanding where you are on that ladder determines your options.

Step one: Warning Letter. This is the lightest outcome. ATF documents the violations, sends you a letter explaining what you did wrong, and expects you to fix it. Historically, 93% of inspections ended here. Under enhanced enforcement, that percentage has dropped significantly.

Step two: Warning Conference. This is more serious. You meet with ATF officials to discuss the violations. The conference is documented. Your expected to demonstrate how you’ll prevent future violations. Warning conferences used to happen in about 4% of cases. That percentage has increased.

Step three: Notice of Revocation. ATF formally notifies you that it intends to revoke your license. You have the right to a hearing before the revocation takes effect. This is were most dealers first realize how serious there situation is – and were they finally call attorneys.

Step four: Revocation. Your license is gone. Your business is over. You cannot sell firearms legally.

Step five: The five-year ban. After revocation, you cannot apply for a new FFL for five years. Your career as a firearms dealer is effectively over.

Todd Spodek has represented FFLs at every step of this ladder. The clients who fare best are the ones who understand the process early – ideally at the Warning Letter stage – and take immediate corrective action while there’s still time.

When Inspections Become Criminal Cases

Heres were compliance inspections can turn into something much worse. IOIs conduct civil regulatory inspections. But if they find evidence of criminal activity, they can refer the case to ATF Special Agents for criminal investigation.

Criminal referrals happen more often then dealers realize. If an IOI finds patterns suggesting straw purchases, evidence of falsified records with intent to deceive, or connections to known trafficking networks, that information goes to Special Agents. Suddenly your not facing license revocation – your facing federal charges.

Straw purchase violations carry up to 15 years in federal prison and $250,000 in fines. If the straw-purchased firearm is used in a felony, act of terrorism, or drug trafficking crime, that sentence can increase to 25 years. Since October 2023, 250 defendants have been charged with gun trafficking under enhanced federal statutes.

Consider the case of Giovanni “Gio” Tilotta, owner of Honey Badger Firearms in San Diego. He was convicted of assisting with unlicensed firearms dealing and conducting straw purchases. His conviction was reportedly the first federal criminal conviction of a civilian retail gun store owner in the Southern District of California in at least 15 years. The case started with compliance issues and escalated to criminal prosecution.

But also consider Aaron Horwat of Gator Guns in Alaska. ATF revoked his license in 2019 after finding 321 missing firearms – after 37 years in business. Instead of accepting the revocation, he fought the case. A jury acquitted him. The lesson? ATF enforcement decisions are not always correct, and fighting back is sometimes the right choice.

The Audit Trail That Follows You

Heres something most FFLs dont realize untill its to late. Every ATF inspection creates a permanant record. Every violation gets documented. Every warning letter, every warning conference, every correction you promised to make – all of it goes into your file. And your file follows you forever.

When ATF comes back for there next inspection – wheather thats next year or five years from now – there not starting fresh. There opening your file first. There reviewing every past violation. There looking at wheather you actualy fixed the problems you said you would fix. If you received a warning letter about incomplete serial numbers in 2019, and they find the same issue in 2024, thats evidence of willfulness. You knew about the problem. You promised to fix it. You didnt.

This is how ATF builds willfulness cases without needing to prove intent. They document a violation. They warn you. They come back and find the same violation. The pattern itself becomes proof that you knew the rules and chose to ignore them. It dosent matter that you were overwhelmed, understaffed, or dealing with supply chain chaos. The file shows you knew.

Heres the hidden trap. ATF dosent have to tell you exactly what there looking for. They can review your entire A&D book. They can examine every Form 4473 youve processed. They can check every serial number against there trace database. If they find something connected to a crime gun – even a gun you sold five years ago that you did everything right on – that transaction becomes a starting point for deeper scrutiny.

The audit trail works against you in another way too. If you ever want to sell your business, the buyer inherits your ATF history. Potential buyers will want to see your inspection record. Warning letters and conferences become disclosed issues in any sale. Your compliance history becomes part of your businesss value – or lack of value.

Todd Spodek advises every FFL client to maintain there own parallel records of every ATF interaction. Document what inspectors said. Keep copies of everything you submit. Create a file that shows your good faith compliance efforts. Becuase when ATF looks at your history, you want to be able to show that history from your perspective too.

The Business Reality Nobody Discusses

Lets talk about what an ATF inspection actualy does to your business – even if it ends with just a warning letter.

Your employees panic. The moment federal agents walk in, your staff assumes the worst. Some of them may quit. Others will talk – to there families, to customers, to other gun dealers. Word spreads fast in this industry. “Did you hear ATF was at Johns store?” It dosent matter that the inspection was routine. The perception is damage.

Your customers notice. If the inspection happens during business hours – which it almost always does – customers see federal agents examining your records. Some will leave and never come back. Others will hesitate before completing purchases. Your reputation takes a hit even if you did nothing wrong.

Your suppliers get nervous. Distributors hear things. If word gets around that your under ATF scrutiny, some may decide your not worth the risk. This is particuarly true if the inspection relates to crime gun traces. Nobody wants to be the supplier who sold inventory to a dealer who ends up in the news.

Your bank asks questions. Financial institutions are already skittish about firearms businesses. An ATF investigation – even a routine compliance inspection – can trigger internal reviews at your bank. Weve seen dealers lose there merchant accounts and banking relationships over inspections that ended with nothing more then a warning letter.

The business damage starts the moment agents arrive, not when findings are issued. Thats why having an attorney involved from minute one matters. Not just for the legal defense, but for managing the situation in a way that minimizes collateral damage to your operations.

What You Should Do Right Now

If ATF is at your store right now, heres exactly what you should do:

First, determine who is there. Are they Industry Operations Investigators conducting a compliance inspection? Or are they Special Agents conducting a criminal investigation? Ask directly. This determines everything.

Do NOT refuse the inspection. If IOIs are there for a compliance inspection and you refuse to let them in, your license is automatically subject to revocation. Refusing inspection is itself a willful violation. It never helps. Ever.

Do NOT volunteer information beyond what’s asked. Answer questions directly and accurately, but dont elaborate. Dont explain why you made mistakes. Dont offer theories about what went wrong. Every word you say is documented and can be used to establish willfulness.

Do NOT argue with inspectors. You will have opportunities to contest findings later. The inspection itself is not the time to fight. Document your disagreements, but dont create a confrontational environment that makes things worse.

DO call an attorney immediatly. Before you answer substantive questions. Before you start producing records. Call a lawyer who understands ATF enforcement. Not your general business attorney – someone who specifically handles FFL matters.

DO document everything. Take notes on what inspectors ask, what records they examine, what they say about violations. This documentation will be absolutly critical for any subsequent proceedings.

DO take any warning letter or violation report seriously. The violations documented today become the “pattern” that supports willfulness findings tomorrow. Fix everything. Document your fixes. Show that you took corrective action immediatly and comprehensively.

Todd Spodek tells every FFL client the same thing: the inspection is not the end. Its the beginning of a process that can go in very different directions depending on how you respond. Getting legal help early – at the inspection stage, not the revocation stage – dramatically improves outcomes.

Call Spodek Law Group at 212-300-5196. Before you sign anything. Before you admit anything. Before your business becomes a statistic in ATF’s revocation reports.

Your license isnt just a piece of paper. Its your livelihood. Protect it accordingly.