Criminal Defense Lawyers

The second thing you need to understand is this: if you’re under FINRA investigation and you try to invoke your Fifth Amendment rights, you will be automatically barred from the industry. Not suspended. Barred. Permanently. Because FINRA isn’t the government, the Constitution doesn’t apply to their proceedings. They’ve structured the entire system so that staying silent isn’t an option. But neither is talking too much. And definitely not lying. You’re walking a corridor so narrow that one wrong step in any direction destroys everything you’ve built.

This is what a FINRA investigation actually is. Not a neutral fact-finding exercise. Not an opportunity to clear your name. It’s a process designed by a private regulator with government-level power and none of the constitutional constraints. Understanding exactly what you’re dealing with is the only way to survive it.

What Triggers a FINRA Investigation

Heres the thing most brokers dont realize until its to late. FINRA dosent need a customer complaint to come after you. They have automated surveillance systems running constantly, algorithms monitoring trading activity across the entire market. If those systems detect unusual patterns – unusual volume, timing that looks suspicious, trades that dont quite fit the normal profile – thats enough to trigger an investigation. No human being has to file anything. The machines are watching.

Beyond the algorithms, investigations get triggered by:

• examination findings
• tips from coworkers or competitors
• referrals from other regulators like the SEC or state agencies
• and even press reports

If your name shows up in a news article about something questionable, FINRA’s enforcement staff may open a file on you that same day. Customer complaints are actually just one of many sources. And heres the part that really matters: before you even receive the first letter, FINRA has likely already pulled your entire employment history from every firm you’ve ever worked at. They’ve reviewed your U4, your U5, your disclosure history. By the time they contact you, they’ve already formed opinions.

The exam programs alone generate enormous enforcement activity. FINRA scoped Reg BI into 1,200 different exams since the rule took effect. In 2024, almost 350 annual exams had Reg BI specifically built in. The exception rate on those exams runs between 50 and 70 percent. Most firms aren’t getting everything right. So you might be investigated not because you did something unusually wrong, but because your doing exactly what everyone else is doing – and FINRA has decided its a problem.

The 8210 Letter: Your First Warning

Your going to learn about a FINRA investigation through something called an 8210 request. Its named after Rule 8210, which gives FINRA the authority to demand documents, information, and testimony from anyone in the industry. When that letter arrives, everything changes.

Heres what the letter wont tell you: whether your the target of the investigation or just a witness. FINRA rarely states this directly. The letter usually says something vague about a “preliminary inquiry” into possible securities violations. It demands documents. It sets a deadline. And it dosent explain whether they think you did something wrong or wheather they just think you might have information about someone else. This ambiguity is intentional. You dont know how to calibrate your response because you dont know your role in the investigation.

What you absolutely cannot do is ignore that letter. One ignored 8210 request can end your career faster then actual misconduct would. FINRA expects strict compliance with Rule 8210, and the penalties for non-compliance are severe – most often a permanent bar from the industry. Ive seen cases were brokers who might of prevailed on the underlying allegations got barred simply because they didn’t respond to the 8210 in time. They destroyed there own careers through inaction.

The Investigation Process Nobody Explains

OK so you responded to the 8210. You produced documents. Now what happens? FINRA dosent just read your paperwork and make a decision. Theres a whole process that unfolds, and most brokers dont understand it untill there already deep inside it.

After the document requests come the OTR interviews. OTR stands for On-the-Record testimony. These are conducted under oath, at FINRA’s offices, with a court reporter present. Heres what nobody tells you about OTRs: there not subject to time limitations. They can go on for hours. They can span multiple days. And while you can have your lawyer present, FINRA’s rules dont allow for objections during the hearing. Your attorney cant object and stop you from answering a question the way they could in a court proceeding. You answer everything, and it all goes on the record.

The questions come in a deposition format. The FINRA examiner asks, you answer. Every answer is transcribed. Every hesitation is noted. And remember – you cant invoke the Fifth Amendment. If you refuse to answer, thats treated as failure to cooperate, which means automatic bar. So your sitting there, under oath, without the constitutional protections that would apply if this were an actual government proceeding, and your expected to answer every question completly and truthfully while somehow not saying anything that expands the investigation or incriminates you. Thats the trap.

If the investigation continues and FINRA believes enforcement action is warranted, youll recieve whats called a Wells Notice. This document summarizes FINRAs conclusions and tells you they intend to pursue formal charges. You get a chance to respond in writing – a Wells submission – to try to persuade them not to file. But by this point, theyve already decided. In 2024, FINRA filed 21 formal complaints. Every single one was against an individual. Not a single complaint was filed against a firm. Think about that.

The Cooperation Paradox

Heres were it gets really weird. FINRA demands your full cooperation. Failure to cooperate means automatic bar. But cooperation itself can destroy you.

Many advisors believe there being helpful by providing FINRA with more information then requested. They think an “open book” strategy shows good faith. But this type of approach can inadvertently harm you by giving FINRA the oportunity to look into areas they might not of paid attention to otherwise. You’ve basicly handed them a roadmap to expand the investigation. What started as questions about one set of trades now includes questions about your entire book of business, your outside activities, your social media posts, things that had nothing to do with the original inquiry.

And yet you cant not cooperate. FINRA Rule 8210 requires industry members to cooperate whenever FINRA beleives a rules violation may have occurred. Notice the language: “may have occured.” They dont need proof. They dont need certainty. They just need to beleive something might of happened. And once they believe that, your required to cooperate fully – or your barred.

So the question isnt whether to cooperate. The question is how to cooperate. How much information do you provide? Exactly what was requested? More? Less? Every answer has consequences. Provide to little and your not cooperating. Provide to much and you’ve expanded the investigation. This is why you need experienced legal counsel from the moment that 8210 letter arrives. The corridor is that narrow.

What FINRA Can Actually Do To You

FINRA is not a government agency. Its a nonprofit self-regulatory organization authorized by Congress. But dont let that fool you. The sanctions FINRA can impose are devastating.

Fines are just the beginning. In 2024, the average fine across all FINRA enforcement actions was $362,547. The median fine for large firms was $375,000. For small firms, $75,000. These numbers can wipe out years of earnings. But fines arent even the worst of it.

Suspensions remove your ability to work in the industry temporarily. You cant earn. You cant serve your clients. Your reputation suffers. And everything goes on your U5 and into BrokerCheck. But even suspensions pale compared to the ultimate sanction: a bar.

When FINRA bars you from the industry, your career is over. Permanently. You cannot work as a broker, cannot associate with any FINRA member firm in any capacity, cannot do the work you’ve trained for and built a career around. FINRA barred more then 730 brokers in the last two years alone. Thats an average of one broker barred every single day.

Look at what happened to Kyle Patrick Harrington. According to FINRA’s findings, he converted about $20,000 from one customer and engaged in undisclosed private securities transactions. The result? Barred from the industry permanently. Ordered to pay $105,000 to reimburse his firm for a customer claim. Ordered to pay an additional $190,974 in disgorgement. One series of violations and his entire career was erased.

Or consider the broker who FINRA barred for churning the account of a 93-year-old customer. He executed more then 3,500 transactions in that single account. Three thousand five hundred trades in one elderly persons account. Thats not a mistake. Thats a pattern. And FINRA caught it through there surveillance systems, the same systems that might be watching your trading activity right now without you knowing.

Then theres the case FINRA publicized about a broker who accepted blank checks from his 87-year-old customer and used them for personal expenditures – including the purchase of a 1976 Corvette. He literaly bought himself a vintage car with a vulnerable clients money. Barred permanantly. These cases sound extreme, but they illustrate how FINRA operates: they investigate, they find patterns, they connect dots, and when they find misconduct, they end careers.

Alpine Securities tried to fight back. FINRA charged them with mishandling client funds and charging unreasonable fees. A hearing panel barred Alpine from the industry entirely and ordered them to pay more then $2 million in restitution. Even firms with resources to fight often loose.

And heres the part that follows you forever: BrokerCheck. Every bar, every suspension, every disciplinary action appears on your permanent record. Its searchable online. Clients can find it. Competitors can find it. Future employers – if there even are any after a bar – can find it. Theres basicly no way to hide it. The investigation might be confidential while its happening, but the outcome is public knowledge for the rest of your professional life.

When FINRA Becomes Criminal

FINRA cannot bring criminal charges. Its not a prosecutor. But that dosent mean a FINRA investigation cant lead to criminal consequences.

FINRA routinely refers matters outside its jurisdiction to government agencies, including the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Department of Justice. If FINRA investigators discover evidence of conduct that might violate federal securities laws or criminal statutes, they share that information. Your regulatory problem becomes a criminal problem.

The SEC can bring civil enforcement actions with significant financial penalties. More importantly, the SEC works closely with DOJ on cases with criminal potential. What started as a FINRA inquiry about whether you followed internal procedures can evolve into a federal investigation about whether you committed wire fraud or securities fraud.

And heres the connection nobody explains: if you destroy documents during a FINRA investigation, thats not just a FINRA violation. Spoliation – the destruction of evidence – is a crime. It can lead to criminal conviction and prison time, completely separate from whatever sanctions FINRA imposes. Ive seen brokers panic when they receive an 8210 letter and there first instinct is to delete emails or destroy records. That instinct can put you in prison.

The information sharing between regulators is more extensive then most people realize. FINRA and the SEC often have parallel jurisdiction over the same conduct. They talk to each other. They share documents. They coordinate. So while your responding to FINRAs 8210 request, thinking your dealing with a regulatory matter, the SEC might already be building a civil case. And if the SEC sees criminal potential, they bring in DOJ. You wouldnt even know about it untill agents show up at your door.

The Timeline Reality

How long does a FINRA investigation take? Theres no simple answer, and thats part of whats so difficult about being under investigation. FINRA’s official position is that they conduct investigations “as expeditiously as possible” but cannot predict how long any particular case will take. That depends on facts and circumstances.

In practice, investigations can drag on for months or years. Document collection takes time. Multiple rounds of 8210 requests are common. OTR testimony gets scheduled weeks or months out. If multiple parties are involved, FINRA is collecting information from all of them and comparing answers. The longer the investigation continues, the more anxious you become – and the more oppurtunities there are for you to make mistakes.

During this entire period, your career hangs in limbo. You might still be working, still serving clients, but theres a cloud over everything. You dont know whats coming. You dont know if this ends with a Cautionary Action – basically a warning – or a permanent bar. You dont know if FINRA will refer the matter to the SEC or DOJ. You wait. And wait. And every day that passes, the stress compounds.

Some investigations end quietly. About 90 percent of examination deficiencies dont get referred to Enforcement. Many investigations close without formal action. But you wont know which category your in untill FINRA decides to tell you. And by then, youve already spent months or years of your life wondering wheather your career will survive.

The Numbers That Should Scare You

Lets talk about whats actually happening in FINRA enforcement right now.

In 2024, FINRA filed 158 Acceptance, Waiver and Consent orders against firms. 81 of those were against small firms, 17 against mid-size firms, 60 against large firms. The median fine for small firms was $75,000. For large firms, $375,000. The average fine across all categories was $362,547.

FINRA filed 21 formal complaints in 2024. Every single one – all 21 – were filed against individuals. Not firms. Individuals. When FINRA decides to litigate rather then settle, there going after specific people. Not corporations. People like you.

The Reg BI examination program has a 50 to 70 percent exception rate. That means the majority of firms examined are not fully compliant. Most of these exceptions dont result in enforcement referrals – only about 10 percent of deficiencies get sent to Enforcement for further investigation. But 10 percent of a large number is still a lot of cases. And if your in that 10 percent, the statistics wont comfort you.

More then 730 brokers have been barred in the last two years. Thats one career ended per day, every day, for two years straight. Some of these bars were for serious misconduct – converting client funds, churning elderly accounts, running unauthorized trading schemes. But some were simply for failing to respond to an 8210 request. Some were for invoking the Fifth Amendment. Some were for not taking the investigation seriously enough.

What To Do If You Get That Letter

The 8210 letter just arrived. What now?

First: dont panic, but take it extremely seriously. Many brokers assume its no big deal, just a routine inquiry, something compliance will handle. That assumption has destroyed careers. Treat every 8210 letter like your professional life depends on it. Because it does.

Second: do not talk to coworkers about the investigation. Talking to coworkers creates additional witnesses, spreads rumors, and can taint other peoples testimony. Keep the investigation between you, your lawyer, and the compliance personel who absolutely need to know. Nobody else.

Third: do not destroy anything. Not emails. Not documents. Not text messages. Nothing. The impulse to clean up your files is understandable but catastrophic. Document destruction during an investigation is spoliation, and it can result in both FINRA sanctions and criminal prosecution. Preserve everything.

Fourth: get a lawyer immediately. Not next week. Now. You need counsel who understands FINRA investigations, who knows how to respond to 8210 requests without over-disclosing or under-disclosing, who can prepare you for OTR testimony, who understands the narrow corridor your walking. This is not something to handle on your own. The stakes are to high.

Fifth: understand that cooperation is mandatory but must be strategic. You cannot invoke the Fifth Amendment. You cannot refuse to produce documents. You cannot ignore deadlines. But you also cannot volunteer information beyond whats requested without potentially expanding the investigation. Every response must be carefully calibrated. This is why experienced counsel is essential.

A FINRA investigation is not neutral. Its not designed to clear your name. Its a process controlled by a regulator with enormous power and very few constraints. The only way through it is to understand exactly what your facing and respond with precision. Anything less and you become another statistic – another broker barred, another career ended, another name on BrokerCheck for the rest of time.

If you’ve received a FINRA 8210 letter or believe you may be under investigation, contact a securities defense attorney immediately. The decisions you make in the first days after receiving that letter will determine whether your career survives.