Blog
Marriage Petition During Federal Case: What You Need to Know
Contents
- 1 Marriage Petition During Federal Case: What You Need to Know
- 1.1 Understanding the Legal Framework
- 1.2 The Critical Timing Factors
- 1.3 Coordinating Criminal Defense and Immigration Strategy
- 1.4 Plea Bargains and Immigration Consequences
- 1.5 Disclosure Requirements and USCIS Communication
- 1.6 Real-World Scenarios and Decision Frameworks
- 1.7 Moving Forward: Your Next Steps
Marriage Petition During Federal Case: What You Need to Know
You just got engaged to the love of your life. You’re ready to start the process of bringing them to the United States or adjusting their status to become a permanent resident. Then it happens—criminal charges. Maybe it’s you facing charges, or maybe it’s your fiance or spouse. Either way, your immigration plans just got a lot more complicated.
The intersection of criminal proceedings and marriage-based immigration petitions creates unique timing challenges that most people don’t anticipate. Unlike completed criminal cases where the outcome is known, pending charges introduce uncertainty into an already complex process.
Key Insight: This article focuses specifically on pending criminal cases – situations where charges are active, outcomes uncertain, and decisions must be made in real-time. If you’re dealing with past convictions, the strategy differs significantly.
What you’ll learn in this guide:
- How timing decisions during criminal proceedings affect immigration outcomes
- Coordinating criminal defense with immigration strategy
- Disclosure requirements for pending charges
- Pre-plea considerations that protect immigration options
- Real-world scenarios with decision frameworks
- What to do if arrested after filing your petition
Legal Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Immigration and criminal law are complex, fact-specific areas. You should consult with qualified attorneys in both fields before making decisions that could affect your immigration status or criminal case.
Understanding the Legal Framework
Before we get into timing strategies, you need to understand how criminal issues affect marriage based immigration petitions. The Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) contains numerous grounds of inadmissibility related to criminal conduct.
Marriage-Based Immigration Overview
A U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident can petition for their spouse using Form I-130 (Petition for Alien Relative). The foreign spouse then either:
- Adjusts status within the U.S. using
Form I-485, or - Processes through a U.S. consulate abroad (consular processing)
Both the petitioner (U.S. sponsor) and the beneficiary (foreign spouse) face scrutiny. However, different standards apply to each.
Criminal Inadmissibility Grounds
Under INA § 212(a)(2), several criminal categories can make someone inadmissible:
- Crimes Involving Moral Turpitude (CIMT)
- Offenses that involve fraud, larceny, intent to harm persons or property. Examples include theft, fraud, assault with intent to injure.
- Multiple Criminal Convictions
- Two or more convictions (regardless of whether they involve moral turpitude) with aggregate sentences of five years or more.
- Controlled Substance Violations
- Drug trafficking or any controlled substance violation (with limited exceptions for single offenses involving 30 grams or less of marijuana for personal use).
- Prostitution and Commercialized Vice
- Engaging in prostitution or procuring prostitutes.
- Certain Serious Crimes
- Crimes for which the applicant asserted immunity from prosecution.
How USCIS Evaluates Criminal Issues
USCIS doesn’t just look at conviction records. They examine:
| Stage | What USCIS Reviews | Immigration Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Arrest | Police reports, booking records, arrest warrant | Must be disclosed; may trigger further scrutiny |
| Charges | Charging documents, indictment, information | Creates uncertainty; may delay processing |
| Pending Case | Court docket, current case status | USCIS may wait for resolution |
| Conviction | Judgment, sentence, statute violated | Determines inadmissibility under categorical approach |
| Post-Conviction | Probation status, completion of sentence | Affects good moral character determination |
Notice that every stage has potential immigration consequences, not just convictions.
The Timing Question: Why It Matters
Here’s what makes pending criminal cases particularly challenging:
“In immigration law, uncertainty is your enemy. USCIS adjudicators prefer clear facts. A pending criminal case creates an open question that makes approval less likely until resolved.”
—Immigration attorney with 15+ years experience
The key timing considerations include:
- Processing time alignment: Will your criminal case resolve before USCIS makes a decision?
- Disclosure obligations: When and how must you inform USCIS of new developments?
- Strategic advantages: Sometimes waiting helps; sometimes it hurts.
- Legal deadline pressures: Some immigration deadlines can’t wait for criminal case resolution.
The Critical Timing Factors
The stage of your criminal case when you engage with the immigration system fundamentally changes your strategy. Let’s examine each scenario.
Before Filing: Criminal Case Already Pending
You have charges pending, and you’re considering whether to file Form I-130 or Form I-485. This is the strategic choice point where you have the most control.
Factors to Consider
- Expected resolution timeline
- Criminal trial in 3 months? Probably wait.
- Case dragging on for over a year? Consider filing with full disclosure.
- Nature of charges
- Serious felony? Absolutely wait for resolution and favorable outcome.
- Misdemeanor with likely diversion? May file with explanation.
- Immigration deadline pressures
- Visa about to expire? May need to file despite pending charges.
- No immediate deadline? Luxury of waiting for clarity.
- Strength of immigration case
- Strong marriage with extensive evidence? Better position to overcome criminal uncertainty.
- Borderline case? Criminal charges may tip scales toward denial.
Warning: Filing before charges resolve means USCIS will see the pending case in their background check. You cannot hide it, and attempting to do so constitutes fraud – a permanent bar to immigration benefits.
During Processing: Arrested After Filing
This scenario creates immediate obligations. You’ve already filed Form I-130 or Form I-485, and now you (or your spouse) face criminal charges.
Your Immediate Action Steps
- Document everything
- Get copies of charging documents
- Obtain police report if available
- Keep all court dates and documents
- Consult both attorneys
- Criminal defense attorney (immediately)
- Immigration attorney (within 48 hours)
- Prepare supplemental evidence
- Character reference letters
- Evidence of community ties
- Employment verification
- Explanation of circumstances
- Update USCIS if required
- Some arrests must be reported immediately
- Others disclosed at interview or if asked
- Your attorney guides disclosure timing
Before Interview: Case Status Changes
Your immigration interview is scheduled, but your criminal case status has changed since filing. Perhaps charges were upgraded, downgraded or partially dismissed.
The rule of thumb: Any material change must be disclosed before your interview. “Material” means:
- New arrests or charges
- Change in charge severity (felony to misdemeanor or vice versa)
- Plea agreements entered
- Convictions or acquittals
- Probation violations
| Change Type | Disclosure Required? | Timing |
|---|---|---|
| Charges dismissed | Yes | Before interview (bring certified court order) |
| Plea agreement reached | Yes | Immediately (affects admissibility analysis) |
| Trial date changed | Usually no | N/A (unless affects ability to attend interview) |
| New arrest | Yes | Immediately |
| Convicted | Yes | Immediately (may need inadmissibility waiver) |
| Case under appeal | Yes | Before interview |
After Approval: Conditional Green Card Complications
If you received a conditional green card (valid 2 years for marriages less than 2 years old at time of approval), criminal charges during this period create serious complications for your Form I-751 (Petition to Remove Conditions).
The challenge: You must file Form I-751 within the 90-day window before your conditional green card expires. If you have pending charges during this window, you face a dilemma:
The I-751 Timing Dilemma
Situation: Your conditional green card expires in 60 days. You have pending assault charges from an incident 4 months ago. Trial is scheduled 3 months from now.
Option 1: File I-751 now with full disclosure of pending charges. Risk: Denial based on failure to maintain good moral character.
Option 2: Wait for trial outcome, possibly missing the 90-day window. Risk: Conditional status expires, creating out-of-status period.
Option 3: File I-751 on time and supplement record after trial. Risk: Still evaluated with pending charges initially.
There’s no perfect answer – only risk management. An experienced immigration attorney can help you navigate these competing pressures.
Coordinating Criminal Defense and Immigration Strategy
Here’s an uncomfortable truth: most criminal defense attorneys know little about immigration consequences, and most immigration attorneys aren’t familiar with criminal procedure. Yet decisions made in one arena profoundly affect outcomes in the other.
The Dual Representation Challenge
You need both attorneys working together, but they often operate in silos. Consider these common disconnects:
- Criminal attorney secures “great” plea deal → Immigration attorney discovers it triggers deportability
- Immigration attorney advises full disclosure → Criminal attorney worries about self-incrimination
- Criminal case resolves favorably → But immigration consequences were never considered
- Immigration deadline pressure → Criminal attorney doesn’t understand urgency
What Your Criminal Attorney Needs to Know
Provide your criminal defense attorney with this information in writing:
Criminal Attorney Information Checklist:
- ☐ Your immigration status (citizen, permanent resident, visa holder, etc.)
- ☐ Your spouse’s immigration status
- ☐ Pending immigration applications (I-130, I-485, etc.) with receipt numbers
- ☐ Immigration interview dates or deadlines
- ☐ Your immigration attorney’s contact information
- ☐ Specific immigration concerns you’re aware of
- ☐ Prior immigration history (deportations, denials, etc.)
What Your Immigration Attorney Needs to Know
Similarly, your immigration attorney needs comprehensive criminal case information:
Immigration Attorney Information Checklist:
- ☐ Arrest date(s) and location(s)
- ☐ All charges (original and current if changed)
- ☐ Statute numbers for each charge
- ☐ Copy of charging document (complaint, indictment, information)
- ☐ Police report (if available)
- ☐ Criminal attorney’s contact information
- ☐ Court dates and case status
- ☐ Anticipated plea offers or trial timeline
- ☐ Any prior criminal history
Joint Strategy Session Framework
Ideally, both attorneys should speak directly. Here’s a framework for a joint consultation:
| Discussion Point | Criminal Attorney Focus | Immigration Attorney Focus |
|---|---|---|
| Charge Analysis | Elements that must be proven | Immigration categorization (CIMT, aggravated felony, etc.) |
| Plea Options | Sentence recommendations, probation terms | Conviction definition, waiver eligibility |
| Timing | Trial prep timeline, continuance options | Immigration deadlines, processing times |
| Evidence | Character evidence for sentencing | Character evidence for immigration petition |
| Disclosure | 5th Amendment concerns | USCIS disclosure requirements |
Pro Tip: Authorize both attorneys in writing to speak with each other. Sign releases allowing information sharing. This facilitates coordination without constant intermediary involvement from you.
Plea Bargains and Immigration Consequences
This section could save your immigration case. Many people accept plea bargains that seem favorable criminally but prove disastrous for immigration.
Understanding “Conviction” for Immigration Purposes
Federal immigration law defines “conviction” more broadly than many state criminal codes. Under INA § 101(a)(48)(A), a conviction occurs when:
- A judge or jury finds you guilty, or
- You enter a guilty plea or no contest plea, and
- A judge orders some form of punishment, penalty, or restraint
This means several state-law “non-convictions” count as convictions for immigration:
- Deferred adjudication (in most cases)
- Withheld judgment
- Pre-trial diversion with guilty plea
- Prayer for judgment continued (in some circuits)
The key: If you admitted guilt and received any consequence (even just probation or community service), immigration law likely treats it as a conviction.
The Categorical Approach Explained
USCIS doesn’t look at what you actually did. They look at what you were convicted of under the statute. This is called the categorical approach.
The categorical approach compares the elements of the statute of conviction to the elements of the generic federal crime definition. If the statute is broader than the generic crime, you’re not convicted of that crime for immigration purposes – even if your actual conduct would qualify.
Example: A state theft statute that covers property valued at any amount is broader than the federal “aggravated felony” theft definition (requires loss to victim exceeding $10,000). Even if you stole $50,000, if you’re convicted under the broad state statute, it’s not an aggravated felony for immigration purposes.
This means the exact statute matters. Different code sections for similar conduct can have vastly different immigration consequences.
Aggravated Felony Traps
The term “aggravated felony” misleads people. In immigration law, it includes crimes that are neither aggravated nor felonies. The immigration consequences are severe:
- Permanent inadmissibility (no waiver available)
- Mandatory detention if in removal proceedings
- Ineligibility for most forms of relief
- Potential denial of marriage petition
Surprisingly minor offenses that can qualify as aggravated felonies:
| Crime Category | Threshold | Common Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Theft/Burglary | Sentence of 1 year or more (even if suspended) | Shoplifting with prior offenses |
| Fraud/Deceit | Loss to victim exceeds $10,000 | Credit card fraud, insurance fraud |
| Tax Evasion | Loss to government exceeds $10,000 | Willful failure to file returns |
| Controlled Substances | Drug trafficking (broadly defined) | Selling small amounts to friends |
| Firearms | Any firearms trafficking | Selling guns without license |
Pre-Plea Immigration Checklist
Before accepting any plea bargain, get answers to these questions:
- ☐ What is the exact statute number I’ll be pleading to?
- ☐ What are the elements of that specific statute?
- ☐ Has my immigration attorney reviewed this statute for immigration consequences?
- ☐ Does this plea create a “conviction” for immigration purposes?
- ☐ Is this offense a crime involving moral turpitude?
- ☐ Could this offense qualify as an aggravated felony?
- ☐ What sentence am I receiving (including suspended time)?
- ☐ Is there an alternative charge with fewer immigration consequences?
- ☐ Would taking this to trial potentially result in better immigration outcomes?
- ☐ If I need an immigration waiver, is this offense waivable?
Questions to Ask Before Accepting Any Plea
Have this conversation with your criminal attorney before any plea:
“I understand this plea seems favorable, but I need to confirm the immigration consequences. Have you consulted with an immigration attorney about this specific statute? Under Padilla v. Kentucky, I know you must advise me of immigration consequences. Can we get written confirmation from an immigration attorney that this plea won’t make me inadmissible?”
If your criminal attorney brushes off these concerns, find a new attorney. Your right to effective assistance of counsel includes competent advice about immigration consequences.
Disclosure Requirements and USCIS Communication
When it comes to criminal issues and immigration applications, the rule is simple: Disclose everything. The penalties for fraud far exceed the consequences of honest disclosure.
Initial Disclosure on Forms
Both Form I-130 and Form I-485 ask detailed questions about criminal history. For pending charges, you must disclose:
- All arrests (even if charges were dropped)
- All citations (even traffic offenses in some cases)
- All pending charges
- All convictions
Form I-485 Specific Questions
On Form I-485, Part 8 asks:
“Have you EVER been arrested, cited, charged, or detained for any reason by any law enforcement official (including USCIS or former INS and U.S. military officers)?”
Notice: EVER and ANY REASON. This is expansive. Even if:
- Charges were dropped
- You were found not guilty
- Records were sealed or expunged
- It happened decades ago
- It was a minor offense
The answer is still YES, and you must provide details.
Arrests vs. Charges vs. Convictions
USCIS treats these distinctly:
| Term | Definition | What to Disclose |
|---|---|---|
| Arrest | Taken into police custody | Date, location, reason for arrest, outcome |
| Citation | Written notice to appear (includes traffic tickets in some cases) | Type of offense, date, outcome |
| Charge | Formal accusation filed in court | All charges (original and amended), statute numbers, current status |
| Conviction | Guilty verdict or plea with sentence imposed | Complete details: charge, sentence, completion status |
Updating USCIS During Processing
What if your criminal case status changes after you file but before your interview? You have affirmative duty to update material changes:
- New arrests: Notify USCIS within 30 days (some attorneys recommend immediately)
- Conviction on pending charge: Update immediately with certified court documents
- Charges dismissed: Provide certified dismissal order before interview
- Plea agreement: Update with plea documents and immigration attorney analysis
Sample USCIS Notification Letter
[Your Name]
[Address]
[Date]U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services
[Field Office Address]RE: Supplemental Information for Case No. [Receipt Number]
Applicant: [Your Name]
Application: Form I-485, Application to Register Permanent ResidenceDear Sir or Madam:
I am writing to provide updated information regarding my pending Form I-485 application. In my original application, I disclosed an arrest on [date] for [charge]. I am writing to inform USCIS that this case has been resolved as follows:
[Describe resolution: dismissed, convicted of reduced charge, etc.]
Attached please find the following certified court documents:
- Disposition order
- Final judgment
- [Other relevant documents]
Please include this information in my pending application file. If you require any additional information or documentation, please contact me at [phone] or [email].
Sincerely,
[Signature]
[Printed Name]
Interview Preparation with Pending Charges
If your interview occurs while charges are still pending, prepare thoroughly:
Interview Document Checklist:
- ☐ Certified copies of all charging documents
- ☐ Current court docket showing case status
- ☐ Police report (if available)
- ☐ Bail/bond paperwork
- ☐ Attorney contact information
- ☐ Character reference letters
- ☐ Evidence of rehabilitation efforts (counseling, classes, etc.)
- ☐ Employment verification
- ☐ Community ties documentation
During the interview, answer questions honestly and completely but don’t volunteer information not asked. If asked about circumstances of the arrest and your criminal attorney advised you not to discuss details, you can state:
“My criminal case is still pending, and on advice of my criminal defense attorney, I cannot discuss the facts of the case while litigation is ongoing. However, I have provided all documentation about the charges and case status, and I will supplement the record once the case is resolved.”
Responding to RFEs About Criminal Issues
USCIS may issue a Request for Evidence (RFE) asking for more information about criminal matters. Typical requests include:
- Certified court documents (disposition, judgment, sentence)
- Police reports
- Explanation of circumstances
- Evidence of rehabilitation
- Updated background check
Respond completely and timely. An RFE gives you a chance to provide context and favorable evidence. Use it strategically.
Real-World Scenarios and Decision Frameworks
Abstract principles become concrete through examples. Let’s walk through common scenarios involving criminal cases and marriage petitions.
Scenario 1: DUI Charge with Pending I-130
Fact Pattern
Situation: Tom, a U.S. citizen, filed Form I-130 for his wife Maria 6 months ago. While the petition is pending, Tom is arrested for DUI (his first offense). His blood alcohol was 0.12%. He’s facing a misdemeanor charge punishable by up to 1 year in jail, though first-time offenders usually get probation.
Legal Analysis
Immigration Impact on Sponsor: A single DUI generally doesn’t disqualify someone from sponsoring a spouse, but USCIS will review good moral character. Multiple DUIs or DUI with aggravating factors (accident, injury, child in car) raise more concerns.
Disclosure Requirements: Tom must notify USCIS of the arrest. If Maria has an interview scheduled, Tom should provide updated information before the interview.
Options Available
- Resolve criminal case first, then update USCIS
- Pro: Shows responsibility, complete record
- Con: May delay I-130 approval if USCIS waits for resolution
- Immediately notify USCIS and proceed with both cases
- Pro: Fulfills disclosure obligations, doesn’t delay immigration
- Con: USCIS evaluates with uncertain criminal outcome
- Pursue diversion program if available
- Pro: May avoid conviction
- Con: Takes time; may still count as conviction for immigration
Recommended Approach
Tom should: (1) Immediately consult an immigration attorney about disclosure timing; (2) Work with criminal attorney to resolve case quickly and favorably; (3) Consider pre-trial diversion or reduced plea; (4) Gather character evidence (employment records, community involvement, lack of prior offenses); (5) Update USCIS once case resolves with certified documents and explanation.
Risk Assessment
Low-Medium Risk: First-time DUI, even with conviction, rarely results in I-130 denial by itself. However, it raises scrutiny. Tom’s overall character profile matters. If he has steady employment, strong marriage evidence, and no other issues, approval remains likely.
Scenario 2: Domestic Violence Arrest During AOS
Fact Pattern
Situation: Priya entered the U.S. on a K-1 fiance visa and married her U.S. citizen husband James. She filed Form I-485 to adjust status 2 months ago. During an argument, a neighbor called police. Although Priya was the victim, both Priya and James were arrested under state mandatory arrest policy. Charges against Priya were dropped after investigation, but James faces domestic violence charges.
Legal Analysis
Immigration Impact: Domestic violence charges against the sponsor (James) are particularly problematic for marriage-based petitions. USCIS scrutinizes these cases for fraud and bona fide marriage concerns. Charges against the beneficiary (Priya) that were dropped should be disclosed but pose less risk.
Bona Fide Marriage Concerns: Domestic violence incidents raise USCIS red flags about marriage legitimacy. However, legitimate marriages can experience domestic conflict. Context matters.
Options Available
- Proceed with AOS and provide full documentation
- Pro: Demonstrates transparency
- Con: Likely triggers enhanced scrutiny
- Wait for criminal case resolution before interview
- Pro: If charges dismissed, shows false accusation
- Con: May miss processing windows; EAD/AP delays
- Pursue self-petition under VAWA if Priya was victim
- Pro: Removes dependency on abusive spouse
- Con: Different legal standard; requires proving abuse
- Provide comprehensive evidence of bona fide marriage despite incident
- Pro: Contextualizes isolated incident
- Con: Difficult to overcome DV concerns
Recommended Approach
This situation requires immediate legal intervention from both criminal and immigration attorneys. Priya should: (1) Obtain certified dismissal of charges against her; (2) Determine if she was the victim (if so, VAWA self-petition may be appropriate); (3) Gather evidence the relationship remains bona fide despite incident; (4) Update USCIS with arrest disclosure and immediate dismissal of charges against her; (5) Consult attorneys about whether to proceed with marriage-based petition or switch to VAWA.
Risk Assessment
High Risk: Domestic violence involving sponsor and beneficiary creates serious concerns for USCIS. Even if charges are dropped, the incident remains in the record. If marriage is genuinely bona fide and this was isolated incident, approval is possible but will require substantial evidence. If Priya was the victim, VAWA may be safer route.
Scenario 3: Drug Charge Before Consular Interview
Fact Pattern
Situation: Carlos, a Brazilian national, is married to Angela, a U.S. citizen. Angela filed Form I-130, which was approved. Carlos is now awaiting his consular interview in Brazil. Before the interview, Carlos was arrested at a music festival in Brazil for possession of MDMA (ecstasy). He faces charges under Brazilian drug laws.
Legal Analysis
Immigration Impact: Controlled substance violations are a grounds of inadmissibility under INA § 212(a)(2)(A)(i)(II). There is a limited exception for simple possession of 30 grams or less of marijuana, but it does not apply to other drugs. MDMA possession likely makes Carlos inadmissible.
Foreign Convictions: Convictions under foreign law count for U.S. immigration purposes if the conduct would be criminal under U.S. federal law (which MDMA possession is).
Options Available
- Postpone consular interview until criminal case resolves
- Pro: If charges dismissed, avoids inadmissibility
- Con: Delays green card; multiple interview rescheduling may raise suspicion
- Fight charges aggressively and seek dismissal or acquittal
- Pro: No conviction means no automatic inadmissibility
- Con: Trial outcome uncertain; may take years
- If convicted, prepare I-601 waiver application
- Pro: Waiver available for simple possession
- Con: Must prove extreme hardship to U.S. citizen spouse; no guarantee of approval
- Consider alternative plea to non-drug offense if possible
- Pro: May avoid inadmissibility ground
- Con: Depends on Brazilian legal system; may not be option
Recommended Approach
Carlos needs both a Brazilian criminal attorney and a U.S. immigration attorney immediately. Strategy: (1) Reschedule consular interview citing personal circumstances (don’t mention arrest until legally required); (2) Aggressively defend criminal case with goal of dismissal or acquittal; (3) If conviction appears likely, negotiate with prosecutor for non-drug offense if possible; (4) Begin gathering extreme hardship evidence for I-601 waiver (Angela’s medical conditions, financial dependence, family ties, country conditions in Brazil); (5) Only proceed with interview after criminal case resolves or with comprehensive waiver package ready.
Risk Assessment
High Risk: Drug charges create serious inadmissibility. However, waivers are available for simple possession (not trafficking). Success depends on: (1) Avoiding conviction if possible; (2) If convicted, demonstrating it was simple possession, not trafficking; (3) Proving extreme hardship to Angela. With proper legal strategy, green card remains possible but far from guaranteed.
Decision Framework: Analyzing Your Situation
Use this framework to think through your specific circumstances:
| Factor | Questions to Ask | How It Affects Strategy |
|---|---|---|
| Charge Severity | Misdemeanor or felony? Possible sentence? Aggravated felony under INA? | More severe = wait for resolution; less severe = may proceed with disclosure |
| Criminal Timeline | Expected resolution timeframe? Trial date set? | Quick resolution = wait; lengthy process = may need to proceed |
| Immigration Timeline | Hard deadlines? Interview scheduled? Status expiring? | Deadlines may force action despite pending charges |
| Likely Outcome | Strong defense? Likely conviction? Plea options? | Favorable outcome likely = wait; conviction likely = get ahead of it |
| Immigration Case Strength | Bona fide marriage? Strong evidence? Other issues? | Strong case can weather criminal uncertainty; weak case cannot |
| Waiver Eligibility | If inadmissible, is waiver available? Extreme hardship? | Waiver available = more options; no waiver = must avoid conviction |
Moving Forward: Your Next Steps
Navigating a marriage petition during a criminal case is complex and high-stakes. The decisions you make now can affect your immigration status for years or permanently.
Key Takeaways
- Timing matters: The stage of your criminal case when you interact with USCIS affects your strategy
- Coordination is critical: Your criminal and immigration attorneys must work together
- Disclosure is mandatory: Always err on the side of transparency with USCIS
- Plea bargains have consequences: Review every plea offer with an immigration attorney before accepting
- Pending charges create uncertainty: USCIS prefers clarity; unresolved cases invite denial
- Context matters: Strong evidence of good moral character and bona fide marriage can overcome single incidents
Immediate Action Steps
If you’re facing criminal charges and have a pending marriage petition (or plan to file one):
- Consult both attorneys immediately
- Criminal defense attorney if you don’t have one
- Immigration attorney experienced with criminal issues
- Document everything
- Arrest records, charging documents, court dates
- Character evidence, employment records, community ties
- Avoid quick decisions
- Don’t accept plea bargains without immigration review
- Don’t file immigration paperwork without criminal case assessment
- Create coordination plan
- Authorize attorneys to speak with each other
- Schedule joint consultation if possible
- Understand your timeline
- Criminal case milestones
- Immigration deadlines
- Where they align or conflict
When to Seek Help
You need professional legal help if:
- You face felony charges
- The offense could be classified as an aggravated felony or crime involving moral turpitude
- You’re considering accepting a plea bargain
- You’ve been arrested after filing an immigration petition
- Your immigration interview is approaching with pending charges
- USCIS issued an RFE or NOID about criminal issues
- You’re a conditional resident facing removal of conditions with pending charges
In these situations, do not proceed without qualified legal counsel. The stakes are too high, and the law too complex, to navigate alone.
Final Reminder: This article provides general information only. Every case is unique. Immigration and criminal law involve fact-specific analysis requiring professional judgment. Consult qualified attorneys in both fields before making decisions that could affect your immigration status or criminal case outcomes.
Your marriage petition represents your future with your spouse in the United States. A criminal case is a serious legal matter. With proper coordination, strategic timing, and qualified legal help, you can navigate both successfully.