Criminal Defense Lawyers

The notice gives you an opportunity to respond before charges are filed. You can submit a written argument – called a Wells Submission – explaining why FINRA should not proceed. But that submission is not privileged. It’s not confidential. Everything you write can be used against you in subsequent proceedings, both regulatory and civil. So the “opportunity” to respond is also a trap – a chance to inadvertently strengthen FINRA’s case while trying to defend yourself.

What a Wells Notice Actually Is

Heres the technical reality. A Wells Notice is a formal communication from FINRA indicating that the enforcement staff intends to recommend disciplinary action against you. Its named after John Wells, who chaired an SEC advisory committee in the 1970s that recommended giving targets notice before enforcement actions were filed. The SEC adopted the practice, and FINRA followed.

Unlike the SEC, FINRA typically delivers the Wells Notice in two parts. First comes the Wells Call – a phone call from FINRA staff informing you of the proposed charges and the primary evidence supporting them. This call is not recorded. It cannot be used as evidence directly. But dont let that fool you into thinking the call is informal. Anything you say on that call can inform how FINRA proceeds. The safest approach is to say very little and reserve your arguments for the written submission.

After the call comes the written Wells Notice confirming what was communicated. This written notice triggers your disclosure obligations. If your a registered representative, you must report the Wells Notice on your Form U4. This means the notice becomes part of your permanent regulatory record, visible on BrokerCheck, discoverable by future employers and clients. The Wells Notice itself – before any charges are even filed – creates a public record that follows you.

The purpose of the Wells process is supposedly to give you a chance to persuade FINRA not to proceed. You get approximately 30 days to submit a written response addressing the proposed charges. FINRA’s independent Office of Disciplinary Affairs reviews your submission alongside the enforcement staff’s recommendations. In theory, a compelling Wells Submission can result in reduced charges, different sanctions, or even a decision not to proceed. In practice, this almost never happens.

The 80% Reality

Lets talk about numbers. Studies have found that 80% of people who receive a Wells Notice from 2011 to 2013 ended up facing charges for allegedly violating securities law. Eight out of ten. Those are not good odds.

This statistic reveals something important about the Wells process: by the time FINRA issues a Wells Notice, they believe they have a strong enough case to proceed. The investigation is complete. The evidence is gathered. The staff has made there preliminary determination. The Wells Notice isn’t an invitation to negotiate from scratch – its a notification that FINRA has already decided you probably did something wrong, and your being given a brief opportunity to change there minds.

Most Wells Submissions dont change anything. One attorney put it bluntly: “A Wells response almost never alters the trajectory of a case.” Despite knowing this, most prospective respondents submit one anyway. Why? Because the alternative – not responding at all – feels like giving up. And because even a low probability of success is better then no attempt. And becuase a well-crafted Wells Submission can lay groundwork for settlement negotiations even if it dosent stop the charges entirely.

But you need to go into this with realistic expectations. The Wells Notice is not your best chance to resolve this matter. Your best chance was earlier in the investigation, before FINRA reached conclusions. By the Wells stage, your primarily preparing for what comes next – whether thats a settlement or a contested proceeding.

What Happens After You Receive One

So the Wells Call came. The written notice followed. You have approximately 30 days. What happens now?

First, you need to decide wheather to submit a response at all. This isnt automatic. A Wells Submission is not privileged or confidential. Everything you write can be used in subsequent enforcement proceedings. It can be made public. It can be discovered in private civil litigation. If you have exposure beyond FINRA – potential SEC issues, civil lawsuits from customers, parallel criminal concerns – your Wells Submission could provide evidence for those other matters.

Second, if you decide to submit, you need to craft something strategic. The submission should address the specific allegations in the Wells Notice. It should explain any exculpatory facts FINRA may have overlooked. It should present legal arguments for why the proposed charges dont fit the conduct. It should highlight mitigating factors that might affect sanctions even if charges proceed. But it should do all this without inadvertently providing new information that strengthens FINRA’s case or expands the investigation into areas they hadn’t previously considered.

Third, you need to understand the review process. FINRA’s Office of Disciplinary Affairs – which is independant of the enforcement staff that investigated you – reviews every Wells Submission before approving settlements or authorizing formal complaints. ODA is charged with evaluating the legal and evidentiary sufficiency of the proposed charges. In theory, ODA provides a check on overreaching by enforcement staff. In practice, ODA rarely blocks charges that enforcement wants to bring.

Fourth, after submitting, you wait. FINRA is not required to respond to your submission. You may hear nothing for weeks or months. Eventually, one of several things happens:

• FINRA decides not to proceed (rare)
• FINRA offers settlement terms you can accept through an AWC (common)
• or FINRA files a formal complaint initiating litigated proceedings (also common)

The Trap Hidden in the Opportunity

Heres what nobody tells you about Wells Submissions. The “opportunity” to respond is also an opportunity to hurt yourself.

A Wells Submission can be ineffective if it fails to address pertinent allegations. But it can be actively harmful if it includes information that tips off enforcement staff to potential charges they hadn’t previously considered. Your trying to defend yourself, and in the process you mention something that expands there case. This happens more often then you’d think.

Think about it from FINRA’s perspective. They investigated. They gathered evidence. They reached conclusions. Then they gave you a chance to respond – and in your response, you revealed additional facts they didnt know, or you made arguments that showed them weaknesses in there case they can now shore up, or you provided written statements they can use as evidence against you later.

The Wells Submission is discoverable in civil litigation. If customers sue you based on the same conduct FINRA is investigating, your Wells Submission can be used in that case. Your written arguments, your factual admissions, your legal positions – all fair game for plaintiffs’ attorneys.

And remember: by submitting a Wells response, your essentially doing FINRA’s job for them. Your identifying the issues you think are important. Your revealing your defense strategy. Your making written statements under circumstances were lying would be catastrophic but telling the whole truth might also hurt you.

Some attorneys advise there clients not to submit at all. Better to save your arguments for settlement negotiations or the hearing itself, were you have more control over the process and more information about FINRA’s exact case. This is a legitimate strategy, though it feels counterintuitive.

Strategic Considerations

If your going to submit a Wells response, here are the strategic realities.

Timing matters. You typicaly have 30 days, though extensions are sometimes granted. This is not much time to craft a comprehensive legal document addressing complex factual and legal issues. You need experienced counsel immediatly – not in a week, not when you “have time.” The clock is running.

Dont plead your innocence on the Wells Call. The phone call is not the venue for substantive arguments. Say as little as possible. Confirm you recieved the notice. Ask clarifying questions about the charges and process. Reserve your actual defense for the written submission, were you have time to be strategic.

Coordinate with other proceedings. If your also facing SEC investigation, civil litigation, or potential criminal exposure, your Wells Submission needs to account for all of these. What you write to FINRA can affect your position elsewhere. This is why you need counsel who understands the full landscape, not just FINRA’s rules.

Consider the disclosure implications. The Wells Notice itself triggers Form U4 disclosure. This means clients, competitors, and future employers will know you received it. The Wells Submission dosent create additional public disclosure, but its contents can become public through other proceedings. Every word you write could eventualy be read by people beyond FINRA.

Evaluate settlement realistically. Many Wells Submissions are written with an eye toward settlement negotiations rather then actually preventing charges. If the goal is settling on favorable terms rather then avoiding charges entirely, the submission should be crafted accordingly.

Real Cases, Real Consequences

Let me give you some context about how this plays out in practice.

FINRA’s enforcement division brought 552 disciplinary actions in 2024 – a 22% increase from the prior year. This was the first increase since 2016, after eight years of declining enforcement activity. The pendulum has swung back toward aggressive enforcement.

Of those 523 settlements through AWCs in 2024, roughly 70% were against individuals, not firms. FINRA isnt just going after institutions. There going after people like you. And every one of those individuals presumably recieved a Wells Notice before the charges were filed.

The types of violations that lead to Wells Notices vary widely:

• Trade reporting failures resulted in 21 cases totaling $9 million in fines.
• Options trading violations produced $4.3 million in fines.
• Reg BI cases numbered 30 with $1.6 million in fines.
• Market manipulation through spoofing generated significant penalties.

These are the issues FINRA cares about – and if your conduct touches any of them, a Wells Notice could be coming.

One particularly troubling trend involves FINRA “weaponizing” the Wells Notice during exams. Some practitioners have observed FINRA examiners issuing Wells Notices based on exam findings without the typical intervening investigation. The exam itself becomes the investigation, and the Wells Notice arrives before you’ve had oportunity to respond substantivly to exam deficiencies. This accelerated process gives you even less time to prepare.

The practical reality is that most people who receive Wells Notices end up settling. Fighting through a full hearing is expensive, time-consuming, and risky. Even if you believe you’d prevail at hearing, the cost-benefit analysis often favors settlement. This means the Wells Notice stage is effectively your last chance to influence the outcome before your locked into the formal process.

What the Wells Notice Means for Your Career

Receiving a Wells Notice is a defining moment in your career. Even if charges are never filed – even if you submit a compelling response and FINRA decides not to proceed – the notice itself creates a permanent record.

The Form U4 disclosure requirement means the Wells Notice appears on your regulatory record. Its visible on BrokerCheck. When clients search your name, they see it. When prospective employers run background checks, they see it. When competitors want to undermine you, they have ammunition.

If charges proceed and you settle through an AWC, the settlement terms become public. If you fight and lose, the hearing decision becomes public. If you fight and win, you’ve still spent months or years under a cloud, paying legal fees, dealing with the distraction and stress.

And throughout this process, your career hangs in the balance. You may still be working, still serving clients, still earning a living. But the Wells Notice is there, casting a shadow over everything. Prospective clients may hesitate. Employers may be nervous. Opportunities may not materialize because of the uncertainty.

This is why the time to address a FINRA investigation is before the Wells Notice, not after. Once you’ve recieved that notice, FINRA has already made there preliminary determination. Your fighting uphill. The investigation phase – before conclusions were reached – offered far more oportunity to shape the outcome.

Many people dont realize they were under investigation untill the Wells Notice arrives. FINRA dosent always telegraph that they’ve opened an enforcement file on you. You might of responded to 8210 requests thinking it was routine. You might of testified at an OTR assuming it was informational. Then suddenly the Wells Call comes, and you realize this was never routine – FINRA was building a case the entire time.

The emotional impact is significant. People describe recieving a Wells Notice as devistating, terrifying, career-defining in the worst way. Everything you’ve worked for suddenly feels precarious. The stress affects your work, your relationships, your health. And you have 30 days to produce a sophisticated legal document while dealing with all of that.

The Bottom Line

A FINRA Wells Notice means the investigation is over and FINRA thinks you did something wrong. You have approximately 30 days to respond. Eighty percent of people who recieve one end up facing charges anyway. Your response is not privileged and can be used against you. The notice itself creates a permanent disclosure on your regulatory record.

Given all this, should you even submit a Wells response? That depends on your specific situation, your exposure in other proceedings, your defense strategy, and your goals. Some people submit comprehensive responses hoping to change FINRA’s mind. Some submit limited responses focused on positioning for settlement. Some dont submit at all.

What you should not do is treat the Wells Notice casually, respond without legal counsel, or assume that a strong submission will make this go away. The Wells process is a narrow window in a process that’s already largely determined. Use it strategicly – or decide strategically not to use it at all.

If you’ve received a FINRA Wells Notice, contact a securities regulatory defense attorney immediately. The 30-day response window is critical, and the decisions you make now will affect both the FINRA proceedings and any related civil or criminal exposure.