Criminal Defense Lawyers

Federal Dental Medicaid Fraud Charges – What You Need to Know

Federal Dental Medicaid Fraud Charges – What You Need to Know

Federal investigators are prosecuting dentists for Medicaid fraud at alarming rates. If your practice bills Medicaid for dental services – especially pediatric dental services – you need to understand what federal prosecutors are looking for. Here is the first thing you should know: dental Medicaid fraud prosecutions result in devastating federal prison sentences. Rene Fernandez Gaviola received 10 years in federal prison for orchestrating a $6 million fraud scheme at his Houston dental clinics. He employed his own son to perform dental procedures on Medicaid-insured children. His son was not a licensed dentist. These are not theoretical outcomes.

Welcome to Spodek Law Group. We handle federal healthcare fraud defense cases regularly, including cases where dentists first realize they are facing serious criminal exposure through exactly this kind of investigation. The second thing you need to understand is this: the Department of Justice views pediatric dental Medicaid billing as one of the most fraud-prone specialties in healthcare. Production quotas. Unnecessary pulpotomies. Steel crowns on healthy teeth. Federal prosecutors have called Medicaid fraud “the most lucrative business model in U.S. dentistry today” – and the sentences are devastating.

Heres something most dentists dont realize about pediatric Medicaid billing. The paradox is brutal. Children receive pulpotomies on teeth that display no signs of decay. Dentists drill holes in healthy molars and fill them with material the child didnt need. Why? Becuase Medicaid pays 3 to 6 times more for stainless steel crowns then it pays for standard fillings. The reimbursement rate determines the treatment, not the patients condition. And children are targeted specificaly becuase they wont notice misshapen crown fit until there permanent teeth come in.

Children as Billing Pawns

Heres the uncomfortable truth about pediatric dental Medicaid fraud. Children are used as billing pawns without regard to there actual dental needs. The DOJ is systematicaly targeting dental practices that perform medically unnecessary procedures on children – and the schemes reveal how reimbursement-driven treatment decisions create criminal exposure.

Gaviola employed his unlicensed son to perform dental procedures. The Houston dentist operated multiple Floss Family Dental clinics. He employed his own son – who was not a licensed dentist – to perform dental procedures on Medicaid-insured children. The clinics submitted $6.9 million in false claims. Medicaid reimbursed $4.9 million. Gaviola received 120 months in federal prison. His clinic manager Mia Diaz received 21 months.

Some clinics operated without any licensed dentists present. The Floss scheme wasnt unique. Federal investigators have found clinics billing Medicaid while unlicensed individuals perform treatment. The billing codes show licensed dentist services. The reality shows people without licenses drilling into childrens teeth. Every claim is false.

Benevis and Kool Smiles paid $23.9 million to settle allegations. The dental management company operated over 130 Kool Smiles clinics in 17 states. The government alleged they performed medically unnecessary pulpotomies and steel crowns on children. The settlement resolved allegations that dentists performed invasive procedures – including baby root canals – on children who didnt need them.

FORBA and Small Smiles paid $24 million. Another pediatric dental chain faced similar allegations. Medically unnecessary procedures performed on children. The pattern is identical. The chain operated nationaly. The settlement resolved False Claims Act liability but didnt address individual criminal exposure for participating dentists.

Think about what this means for your dental practice. If your treatment decisions are influenced by which procedures generate higher reimbursements, thats not aggressive billing. Thats healthcare fraud. The crown that seemed like appropriate treatment becomes the evidence that proves criminal intent.

The Production Quota System

Heres something about dental Medicaid fraud that reveals how corporate pressure creates criminal exposure. Production quotas turn dentists into billing machines – and the pressure to meet revenue goals leads directly to federal prosecution.

Kool Smiles disciplined “unproductive” dentists. The dental management company set production goals for each clinic. Dentists who failed to meet quotas were disciplined. Dentists who exceeded quotas received cash bonuses. The metric wasnt patient outcomes. The metric was revenue generated. When your employer rewards you for billing more procedures – regardless of wheather patients need them – the incentive structure creates fraud.

Production goals drove unnecessary pulpotomies. A pulpotomy is basicly a baby root canal. Its invasive. Its painful. And Medicaid pays significantly more for pulpotomies then for simple fillings. When dentists face pressure to meet production quotas, they recommend the more expensive procedure regardless of patient need. The child suffers. The dentist bills. Medicaid pays.

The disciplinary structure proves intent. When federal investigators examine dental practices, they look for evidence that treatment decisions were driven by financial pressure rather then medical necessity. Production quotas are that evidence. Discipline for low production is that evidence. Bonuses for high production is that evidence. The corporate structure that seemed like normal business practice becomes the proof of fraudulent intent.

One dentist was responsible for 31% of all dental Medicaid billings for general anesthesia in an entire state. Let that sink in. One dentist. 31% of the entire states anesthesia billings. Thats not a productive practice. Thats a statistical impossibility that triggers investigation. That dentist received 12 years in federal prison.

The Unlicensed Treatment Scheme

Heres something about dental Medicaid fraud that should terrify every practice owner. If unlicensed individuals perform dental procedures in your clinic – regardless of your knowledge – you face federal prosecution.

Gaviolas son was not a licensed dentist. The Houston scheme wasnt just about billing unnecessary procedures. It was about unlicensed individuals performing dental treatment and billing as if licensed dentists performed the work. Every claim that stated a licensed dentist performed the procedure was false. The government didnt need to prove the procedures were medically unnecessary. The unlicensed provider made every claim fraudulent.

Clinic managers and owners face prosecution too. Mia Diaz was Gaviolas clinic manager. She received 21 months in federal prison. She didnt personally perform the unlicensed dental work. She managed the operation that facilitated it. The conspiracy charge reaches everyone who participated.

Supervision claims dont protect you. Some practices argue that licensed dentists “supervised” procedures performed by unlicensed staff. That argument fails. If the billing code indicates a licensed dentist performed the procedure, and someone else actualy performed it, the claim is false. Supervision is irrelevant to the billing code submission.

International Dental Associates used patient recruiters in kickback schemes. The DC-area practice paid kickbacks to bring Medicaid patients to there clinics. The kickback payments created Anti-Kickback Statute violations on top of false claims liability. Every patient obtained through kickback arrangements generates tainted claims.

The Kickback Pipeline

Heres something about how dental Medicaid fraud actualy works. Its not just about billing unnecessary procedures. Its about paying people to deliver Medicaid patients to your practice – and those payments create federal criminal exposure.

Caregivers receive payments to bring children to clinics. The kickback pipeline works like this: dental clinic pays caregiver to bring Medicaid-insured child. Caregiver brings child. Dentist performs procedure – necessary or not. Medicaid pays. Caregiver receives there cut. Cycle repeats. Every payment to the caregiver is a potential Anti-Kickback violation. Every claim submitted for that patient is a false claim.

Marketers recruit Medicaid patients for payment. Some schemes use professional recruiters. The recruiter identifies families with Medicaid-insured children. The recruiter steers families to specific dental practices. The recruiter receives payment based on patient volume. The Anti-Kickback Statute prohibits payments for patient referrals. The arrangement that seemed like marketing becomes federal prosecution.

The kickback taints every claim. Once a patient is obtained through kickback arrangement, every service billed for that patient is potentialy fraudulent. The procedure itself might be medically necessary. The billing code might be accurate. But the referral was tainted. And tainted referrals create false claims liability.

Bus transportation and gift cards trigger scrutiny. Some practices provide transportation to bring Medicaid patients to there clinics. Some provide gift cards or other incentives. These arrangements may constitute illegal remuneration under the Anti-Kickback Statute. The convenience that seemed like good patient service becomes evidence of fraud.

The Cases That Show What Happens

If you think federal dental Medicaid fraud prosecutions are theoretical, look at what actualy happens to dentists when these schemes collapse.

Rene Fernandez Gaviola received 10 years in federal prison. The Houston dentist operated the Floss Family Dental scheme from his multiple clinics. He employed his unlicensed son. He submitted $6.9 million in false claims. He was ordered to pay $4.9 million in restitution. Ten years in federal prison for running a pediatric dental fraud operation.

Mia Diaz received 21 months in federal prison. The clinic manager who facilitated Gaviolas scheme. She didnt perform dental procedures. She managed the billing operation. 21 months in federal prison for her role in the conspiracy.

Dr. Barry Jacobson paid $753,457 to settle allegations. The New York pediatric dentist was accused of performing unnecessary baby root canals on children. He resolved his civil liability through settlement. The settlement didnt include prison time – but it required payment of over three quarters of a million dollars.

Ocean Dental and Dr. Lockwood paid $5 million. The Oklahoma scheme resulted in both civil settlement and criminal prosecution. Dr. Lockwood received 18 months in federal prison. The practice paid millions in settlement. Civil and criminal liability can run paralel.

Drs. Dhir and Puri paid $3.1 million. The Texas dentists operated 35 clinics serving Medicaid children. The government alleged they billed for fillings that were never performed. They submitted claims for dental work they didnt do. The settlement resolved civil liability for a multi-clinic operation.

MDC Holdings paid $10 million. The North Carolina dental company settled allegations of unnecessary pulpotomies. Michael DeRose and Letitia Ballance faced individual liability. Corporate settlement doesnt protect individual participants.

Heres the uncomfortable truth about dental Medicaid fraud prosecutions. When federal investigators examine your billing patterns, they compare your treatment decisions to what patients actualy needed. They interview parents. They review dental records. They analyze wheather your production levels make medical sense. The gap between billing codes and clinical reality becomes the evidence that convicts you.

These arnt unusual cases. They represent standard enforcement outcomes. The sentences reach 10 years. The restitution reaches millions. The practices that seemed profitable collapse when investigation begins.

How Dental Medicaid Investigations Begin

Heres something about how these cases develop that should concern every dentist billing Medicaid. Investigations often begin long before anyone contacts you.

Billing patterns trigger Medicaid audit. If your practice performs significantly more pulpotomies then similar providers, thats flagged. If your crown-to-filling ratio is unusualy high, thats flagged. If your general anesthesia billing represents an impossible percentage of statewide claims, thats flagged. Medicaid data analytics identify statistical outliers. Outliers trigger investigation.

Whistleblowers file qui tam lawsuits. Employees who witness billing fraud can file False Claims Act lawsuits and receive 15-30% of any recovery. That dental assistant who questioned why you were recommending crowns for healthy teeth. That billing staff member who refused to submit claims they knew were false. They can become government informants with financial incentive to expose everything.

Parents complain about unnecessary treatment. When a child receives multiple pulpotomies and crowns in a single visit, parents notice. When the childs permanent teeth emerge and the crown work makes no sense, parents complain. Complaints to state dental boards. Complaints to Medicaid. Complaints that trigger investigation.

State Medicaid agencies refer cases to federal prosecutors. State audits that reveal billing irregularities get referred to federal authorities. What starts as a state Medicaid review becomes a federal criminal investigation. The audit that seemed like routine compliance review becomes prosecution.

Competitor dentists report suspicious billing. When one dental practice in a region performs dramatically more high-reimbursement procedures then everyone else, competitors notice. They report. They provide the statistical comparison that shows your billing is impossible.

What You Cannot Do When Investigated

Heres what people do when they learn about dental Medicaid fraud investigations. They panic. They try to fix things. They make decisions that create additional criminal exposure.

Do NOT destroy patient records or billing documentation. Dental records, treatment plans, billing files, production reports. Destroying any of this is obstruction of justice. The government probly already has copies through Medicaid claims data. Destruction proves consciousness of guilt.

Do NOT alter treatment records to justify past billing. If your records dont support the procedures you billed, your natural instinct is to add clinical findings that would justify the treatment. Dont. Backdating records is additional fraud. Document creation dates can be forensicaly determined. The cover-up becomes additional charges.

Do NOT contact employees to coordinate stories. If staff members witnessed problematic billing practices, your natural instinct is to talk to them. Dont. They may already be cooperating with the government as whistleblowers. Your conversation could be recorded. Coordination is witness tampering.

Do NOT assume the audit will resolve quietly. Dentists often think Medicaid audits are routine billing disputes. By the time federal investigators contact you, the audit phase is over. They have billing patterns. They have patient interviews. They have employee statements. You need an attorney before you say anything.

The False Claims Math

Heres something about dental Medicaid fraud that exponentialy increases legal exposure. False Claims Act penalties apply per claim – and every patient visit is a seperate claim.

How the multiplier works. Each false claim carries penalties of up to $27,894. A dental practice seeing 30 Medicaid patients per day creates 30 potential false claims per day. Over a year, thats over 7,800 claims. At maximum penalties, thats theoretical exposure exceeding $217 million from False Claims Act liability alone.

Healthcare fraud adds criminal exposure. 18 U.S.C. 1347 provides up to 10 years imprisonment per count of healthcare fraud. Health care kickbacks add up to 10 years per count. Wire fraud adds up to 20 years per count. Money laundering adds up to 10 years per count. The civil penalties stack on top of criminal sentences.

Treble damages multiply everything. False Claims Act provides for treble damages – three times the amount defrauded. If your billing fraud cost Medicaid $1 million, treble damages equals $3 million. Plus per-claim penalties. Plus criminal fines. Plus restitution. The Gaviola scheme defrauded Medicaid of $4.9 million – his restitution matched that amount.

Mandatory exclusion from federal healthcare programs. Conviction for healthcare fraud triggers mandatory exclusion from Medicaid and Medicare. You cannot bill federal programs. You cannot work for employers who bill federal programs. Your career as a dentist treating Medicaid patients is over.

State licensing consequences follow federal conviction. Federal healthcare fraud conviction typicaly results in loss of state dental license. The state dental board revokes your license permanantly. Even if you avoid exclusion from federal programs, you may lose your ability to practice dentistry entirely. The federal prosecution destroys both your federal billing privileges and your state license.

What You Should Do Right Now

If federal investigators have contacted you about dental Medicaid billing, or if your billing practices might trigger scrutiny, heres exactly what you should do:

Contact a federal healthcare fraud defense attorney immediatly. Not a general business lawyer. Not your malpractice carrier. Someone who specificaly handles federal healthcare fraud cases and understands Medicaid dental billing prosecution.

Do NOT speak to investigators without counsel. Federal agents may approach you or your staff for “voluntary” interviews. There is nothing voluntary about it. Anything said can be used to build the case against you. Politely decline and contact an attorney immediatly.

Preserve all documentation exactly as it is. Patient records, treatment plans, billing files, production reports, employment records. Do not alter, destroy, or organize anything. Document preservation is critical.

Identify all potentially problematic billing patterns. Pulpotomies and crowns that may lack medical necessity. Production quotas that pressured treatment decisions. Any arrangements that involved payments for patient referrals. Your attorney needs to understand the full scope.

Do NOT discuss the investigation with staff, recruiters, or anyone else. Anyone you talk to can be compelled to testify. They may already be cooperating with the government. Only attorney-client communications are protected.

Todd Spodek tells every dentist in this situation the same thing: federal dental Medicaid fraud investigations are serious criminal matters. Rene Gaviola got 10 years for employing his unlicensed son and billing unnecessary procedures. The dentist who represented 31% of statewide anesthesia billings got 12 years. Your response in the next few days could determine wheather this becomes a matter that resolves favorably – or federal charges that destroy your practice and your freedom.

Call Spodek Law Group at 212-300-5196. Before you speak to federal investigators. Before you make decisions that create additional criminal exposure. Before a billing practice becomes a federal fraud prosecution.

Federal dental Medicaid fraud is an enforcement priority. The DOJ is activly targeting pediatric dental practices that perform unnecessary procedures on children. The sentences reach 10 years in federal prison. The restitution reaches millions. What you do right now matters enormosly.