Blog
Federal Ambulance Service Fraud Charges – What You Need to Know
Contents
Federal agents are investigating ambulance companies across the country. The Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General has made ambulance fraud an enforcement priority. If your company has been transporting patients who could have traveled by other means, or if your billing practices have come under scrutiny, you need to understand what your facing. Here is the first thing you should know: ambulance fraud prosecutions result in serious federal prison sentences. Clifford Shoemake received 71 months in federal prison for his role in a $10.8 million Medicare ambulance fraud scheme in Guam – the largest single Medicare ambulance fraud case prosecuted. His co-defendant Casey Conner received 63 months. A Los Angeles ambulance company manager received 78 months for a $5.5 million scheme. These are not theoretical outcomes.
Welcome to Spodek Law Group. We handle federal healthcare fraud defense cases regularly, including cases where ambulance company owners first realize they are facing serious criminal exposure through exactly this kind of contact. The second thing you need to understand is this: the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services estimates that $350 million is ripped off annually through ambulance fraud. One in five ambulance services have at least one type of questionable bill according to federal audits. Federal prosecutors view ambulance transport as a fraud-prone sector – and the sentences are devastating.
Heres something most ambulance company owners dont realize about how these cases develop. The paradox is brutal. Patients who walked to ambulances were transported at higher rates then patients who truly needed them. Ambulatory patients are more profitable becuase they require less care during transport. The same transport documented as “bed-confined” would show the patient walking into the dialysis center moments later. The crime isnt transporting patients who needed to get somewhere. The crime is transporting patients who could have safely traveled by other means – and billing Medicare as if ambulance transport was medically necessary.
The Transport That Creates Criminal Liability
Heres the uncomfortable truth about ambulance fraud. Medicare only pays for ambulance transport when the patient is bed-confined and cannot travel safely by any other means. That requirement exists before, during, and after transport. If your patient can sit in a wheelchair, they dont qualify. If your patient can transfer to a car seat, they dont qualify. If your patient walked into the facility after you transported them, the transport wasnt medically necessary.
The bed-confined requirement is the entire basis for ambulance reimbursement. Medicare regulations are specific. The patient must be unable to get up from bed without assistance. The patient must be unable to ambulate. The patient must be unable to sit in a wheelchair or regular vehicle. If any of these conditions are not met, the ambulance transport is not covered – and billing for it is fraud.
Ambulatory patients are transported because theyre profitable. Heres the irony that destroys ambulance companies. A patient who can walk requires less medical attention during transport. Less work for the EMTs. Less equipment used. But the billing is the same as a truly bed-confined patient. So ambulance companies transport ambulatory patients, document them as bed-confined, and collect Medicare payments for services that werent medically necessary.
Anthony Nwosah submitted ambulance claims for patients transported in vans. The Texas scheme involved over 2,000 fake transport records. He billed Medicare for ambulance services when patients were actualy transported in vans – claiming emergency service for van rides. The records used a real EMTs name who never worked for the company. Identity theft to commit fraud.
Think about what that means for your ambulance company. Every transport where the patient could have traveled by other means is a potentially fraudulent claim. Every documentation change that removes references to patients walking is evidence of intent. Every pattern of billing for patients who dont meet bed-confined requirements creates federal exposure.
The Documentation Problem
Heres something about ambulance fraud that creates massive criminal exposure. The documentation edits that seem like routine corrections become the primary evidence of fraud.
Guam Medical Transport removed “walk” references from internal documents. The company systematicaly edited transport records to remove any indication that patients could ambulate. References to patients walking to the ambulance. References to patients walking into facilities. References to patients being ambulatory. All removed. Those documentation edits became the federal evidence that proved intentional fraud.
The problem isnt what you documented. Its what you deleted. When investigators compare your internal notes to your submitted claims, every discrepancy becomes evidence. Your EMTs original note said “patient ambulatory.” Your submitted claim said “bed-confined.” That change is the crime. The government dosent need to prove the patient wasnt sick. They need to prove you knew the patient wasnt bed-confined and submitted the claim anyway.
EMTs are instructed to document for billing, not accuracy. Heres the consequence cascade. Management tells EMTs what to write. EMTs fabricate vital signs and symptoms to support medical necessity. Mileage is inflated. Condition descriptions are exaggerated. Every falsified detail on a transport record converts a valid transport into a false claim. And every EMT who participated becomes a potential cooperating witness.
Heres the irony that should terrify every ambulance company owner. The documentation practices you implemented to maximize reimbursement are now the evidence being used to prosecute you. The training you provided to EMTs about “proper documentation” is now evidence of a scheme to defraud. The records you thought protected your billing are now the records that prove your guilt.
The Dialysis Pipeline
Heres something about ambulance fraud that creates recurring criminal exposure. Dialysis patients need regular transport – creating a consistent billing opportunity that attracts fraudulent schemes.
Dialysis patients are transported three times per week. Every week. For years. Thats 156 transports per patient per year. A patient roster of 50 dialysis patients generates 7,800 transport claims annually. At several hundred dollars per transport, a single dialysis relationship can generate over a million dollars in annual billing. The revenue is irresistible.
The problem is most dialysis patients dont need ambulance transport. They need transport. Not ambulance transport. Many dialysis patients are ambulatory. They walk into the dialysis center. They sit in a chair for treatment. They walk back out. They could travel in a wheelchair van or regular vehicle. But ambulance transport pays more then van transport – so ambulance companies transport them anyway.
Kickback schemes develop around dialysis referrals. Heres the hidden connection. A dialysis center employee instructs the ambulance company which patients to transport. The ambulance company falsifies records to make patients appear bed-confined. The ambulance company bills Medicare at ambulance rates. Kickbacks flow back to the dialysis center employee. Everyone profits except Medicare.
A California dialysis-ambulance kickback scheme involved $6 million in fraudulent transports. The dialysis center employee coordinated the referrals. The ambulance company falsified the documentation. Both were prosecuted. The referral relationship that seemed like legitimate business development was actualy a federal crime.
The recurring nature of dialysis transport creates compounding liability. A single dialysis patient transported unnecessarily three times per week for two years generates over 300 false claims. At $27,894 per claim in False Claims Act penalties, thats over $8 million in exposure from one patient. Multiply that across a dialysis patient roster and the numbers become astronomical. The steady revenue stream that seemed so attractive becomes steady evidence of ongoing fraud – each transport another count, each week another three violations, each year another 156 false claims per patient.
The Cases That Show What Happens
If you think federal ambulance fraud prosecutions are theoretical, look at what actualy happens to ambulance company owners and operators.
Clifford Shoemake received 71 months in federal prison. Casey Conner received 63 months. They operated Guam Medical Transport and orchestrated a $10.8 million Medicare ambulance fraud scheme – the largest single Medicare ambulance fraud case. They submitted claims for ambulance transports that werent medically necessary, systematicaly removing documentation that patients could walk. Both were ordered to pay full restitution.
Penn Choice Ambulance owner received 8 years in federal prison. The $3.6 million scheme involved recruiting patients who could walk – not patients who needed ambulance transport. The owner paid kickbacks for patient referrals. The patients were transported by ambulance when they could have traveled by wheelchair van or regular vehicle. Eight years becuase ambulatory patients were billed as bed-confined.
A Los Angeles ambulance company manager received 78 months. The $5.5 million scheme involved systematic false claims for ambulance transports that werent medically necessary. Over six years in federal prison for submitting claims that Medicare should not have paid.
Anthony Nwosah was convicted in Texas for a $3 million scheme. He created over 2,000 fake transport records. The records used a real EMTs name who never actualy worked for the company – identity theft layered on top of healthcare fraud. Patients were transported in vans but billed as ambulance transports. Van rides submitted as emergency ambulance services.
Nine Florida hospitals paid $7.5 million to settle unnecessary ambulance ride allegations. A New York ambulette scheme involved $16 million in fraud, driving beneficiaries to non-existent appointments. The schemes operate across the country. The enforcement follows.
These arnt unusual cases. They represent standard enforcement outcomes. The prison sentences reach over six years. The restitution orders are in the millions. The schemes that seemed sustainable for years collapse when investigation begins.
Courtesy Transport Services in Florida paid $900,000 to settle allegations. The whistleblower who reported the company recieved $171,000 – nearly 20% of the recovery. Thats the financial incentive structure that makes ambulance fraud so dangerous. Your employees, your competitors, your former staff – anyone who suspects problematic billing has powerful motivation to report. And the government rewards them handsomly for doing so.
Hospital “swapping” schemes create additional exposure. Heres the hidden connection that many ambulance companies dont understand. You agree to handle unprofitable hospital runs in exchange for exclusive access to profitable referrals. That exchange is a kickback. The “swapping” arrangement that seemed like legitimate business negotiation is actualy an Anti-Kickback Statute violation. Every transport that flows from that arrangement becomes a tainted claim.
How Ambulance Fraud Investigations Begin
Heres something about how these cases develop that should concern every ambulance company owner. Investigations often begin long before anyone contacts you.
Medicare data analytics identify billing anomolies. Your claims are compared against statistical norms. If your company bills significantly more ambulance transports then similar providers, thats flagged. If your bed-confined transport rate exceeds regional averages, thats flagged. If certain referral sources generate unusual volumes, thats flagged. The investigation starts with data – before anyone visits your facility.
Whistleblowers have massive financial incentive to report. Under the False Claims Act qui tam provisions, whistleblowers can recieve 15-30% of government recoveries. Your EMTs, your billing staff, your former employees, your competitors – anyone who sees something questionable has powerful financial motivation to report it. A whistleblower received $171,000 from the Courtesy Transport Services settlement. Thats $171,000 for reporting their employer.
One investigation exposes the entire network. When the government investigates a dialysis center that coordinated ambulance referrals, every ambulance company that recieved those referrals becomes a target. When they investigate a corrupt marketer, every provider that paid that marketer becomes a target. You may become a target becuase someone in your referral chain was investigated first.
Heres the consequence cascade that destroys ambulance companies. The OIG identifies unusual billing patterns at your company. They subpoena your transport records. They compare your internal documentation to your submitted claims. They discover the discrepancies. They interview your EMTs. The EMTs cooperate to protect themselves. The documentation practices you implemented become the evidence that convicts you.
What You Cannot Do When Investigated
Heres what people do when they learn about ambulance fraud investigations. They panic. They try to fix things. They make decisions that create additional criminal exposure.
Do NOT destroy or alter transport records. Patient records, transport documentation, billing files, contracts with referral sources. Destroying any of this is obstruction of justice. The government probly already has copies through Medicare claims data and records seized from referral partners. Destruction proves consciousness of guilt while accomplishing nothing.
Do NOT contact dialysis centers, referral sources, or EMTs to coordinate stories. If you had problematic referral arrangements or documentation practices, your natural instinct is to talk to others involved. Dont. Coordinating testimony is witness tampering. They may already be cooperating with the government. Your conversation could be recorded.
Do NOT continue questionable transport practices. If your transporting patients who could travel by other means, stop. But dont try to “clean up” by restructuring contracts or creating backdated documentation. Thats additional fraud.
Do NOT assume cooperation will protect you. Ambulance company owners often think full cooperation will result in leniency. Cooperation might help at sentencing if your convicted. But it dosent prevent prosecution. Everything you say to investigators can be used against you. You need an attorney before you say anything.
The False Claims Math
Heres something about ambulance fraud that exponentialy increases legal exposure. Every unnecessary transport creates False Claims Act liability – and the math is devastating.
How the false claims multiplier works. You transport a patient who could have traveled by other means. That transport is billed to Medicare. Medicare pays. That payment is a false claim. Each false claim carries penalties of up to $27,894 (as of 2024). Plus treble damages – three times the governments loss. A company processing 500 unnecessary transports annually creates massive exposure before you even count the underlying transport costs.
The per-transport exposure compounds rapidley. If Medicare paid $400 per transport, and you submitted 500 unnecessary claims, thats $200,000 in Medicare payments. Treble damages: $600,000. Per-claim penalties at even $20,000 each: $10 million. A scheme that generated $200,000 in revenue creates over $10 million in potential liability.
Each transport is a seperate claim. If your company processed 1,000 dialysis transports through problematic practices, you face 1,000 potential false claims. The math destroys companies. The exposure destroys owners. The scheme that seemed profitable becomes financial devastation.
$350 million annually is the CMS estimate for ambulance fraud. One in five ambulance services have questionable bills. The enforcement resources dedicated to ambulance fraud reflect the scale of the problem. The investigations will continue. The prosecutions will continue. The only question is wheather your company is next.
The forfeiture provisions compound the financial devastation. When the government prosecutes ambulance fraud, they dont just seek restitution. They seek forfeiture of assets purchased with fraud proceeds. Your ambulances. Your facility. Your bank accounts. Your personal vehicles. Anything that was purchased with money derived from fraudulent billing is subject to seizure. The scheme that seemed profitable becomes total financial destruction.
Civil monetary penalties stack on top of criminal exposure. The Office of Inspector General can pursue civil monetary penalties seperate from criminal prosecution. Up to $100,000 per false claim. Plus treble damages. Plus exclusion from federal healthcare programs – permanantly. Even if you avoid prison, the civil liability can bankrupt you. Even if you keep your freedom, you lose your ability to ever bill Medicare again.
What You Should Do Right Now
If federal investigators have contacted you about ambulance billing, or if your transport practices might trigger scrutiny, heres exactly what you should do:
Contact a federal healthcare fraud defense attorney immediatly. Not a general business lawyer. Not your liability carrier. Someone who specificaly handles federal healthcare fraud cases and understands HHS-OIG enforcement priorities.
Do NOT speak to investigators without counsel. Federal agents may approach you or your staff for “voluntary” interviews. There is nothing voluntary about it. Anything said can be used to build the case against you. Politely decline and contact an attorney immediatly.
Preserve all documentation exactly as it is. Transport records, billing files, contracts with referral sources, EMT documentation, dispatch records. Do not alter, destroy, or organize anything. Document preservation is critical.
Identify all potentially problematic transport patterns. Dialysis transports. Recurring patients. Referral relationships. Any transports where medical necessity documentation may not support the billing. Your attorney needs to understand the full scope.
Do NOT discuss the investigation with staff, referral sources, or EMTs. Anyone you talk to can be compelled to testify. They may already be cooperating with the government. Only attorney-client communications are protected.
Todd Spodek tells every ambulance company owner in this situation the same thing: federal ambulance fraud investigations are serious criminal matters. Clifford Shoemake got 71 months. The Penn Choice owner got 8 years. One in five ambulance services have questionable bills. Your response in the next few days could determine wheather this becomes a matter that resolves favorably – or federal charges that destroy your company and your freedom.
Call Spodek Law Group at 212-300-5196. Before you speak to investigators. Before you make decisions that create additional exposure. Before a transport pattern becomes a federal prosecution.
Federal ambulance fraud is an enforcement priority. $350 million annually. What you do next matters enormosly.