Criminal Defense Lawyers

Federal Addiction Treatment Center Fraud Charges

Federal Addiction Treatment Center Fraud Charges – What You Need to Know

Federal agents are investigating addiction treatment centers across the country. The Department of Justice has made sober home fraud and patient brokering an enforcement priority. If your facility has been paying for patient referrals, receiving kickbacks from testing laboratories, or working with body brokers, you need to understand what your facing. Here is the first thing you should know: addiction treatment fraud prosecutions result in devastating federal prison sentences. Jonathan Markovich received 188 months in federal prison – over 15 years – for his role in a $112 million South Florida addiction treatment fraud scheme. His brother Daniel received 97 months. Michael Brier received more than eight years for operating a Rhode Island treatment chain that billed for services never provided. These are not theoretical outcomes.

Welcome to Spodek Law Group. We handle federal healthcare fraud defense cases regularly, including cases where treatment facility operators first realize they are facing serious criminal exposure through exactly this kind of contact. The second thing you need to understand is this: the DOJ Sober Homes Initiative has made addiction treatment fraud a primary target. In its first year alone, the initiative charged defendants in connection with over $845 million in allegedly false and fraudulent claims. Federal prosecutors view addiction treatment as a fraud-prone sector – and the sentences are devastating.

Heres something most treatment facility operators dont realize about how these cases develop. The paradox is brutal. Addiction treatment facilities paid patients cash kickbacks – and patients used that cash to buy drugs. Body brokers introduced patients to drug dealers. Sober homes kept patients in a “relapse cycle” becuase recurring treatment was more profitable then actual recovery. The more a patient relapsed, the more valuable they became. The crime isnt treating addiction. The crime is treating addiction as a profit center rather then a disease.

The Body Broker Pipeline

Heres the uncomfortable truth about body brokering. The referral relationships that fill your treatment facility may be illegal kickback arrangements – and the consequences are devastating.

Casey Mahoney paid $2.9 million to body brokers. The California addiction treatment facility operator paid kickbacks to recruiters who found him patients. Those body brokers in turn paid thousands of dollars in cash to patients – cash that some patients used to purchase drugs. Brokered patients were sometimes dropped off at motels in Orange County and introduced to drug dealers. Some of these patients later overdosed and died. Mahoney received 41 months in federal prison.

The body broker pipeline is the hidden engine of addiction treatment fraud. Heres the hidden connection. A body broker recruits an addict. The broker gets paid by your facility. The broker pays the patient a cash kickback. The patient uses that cash to buy drugs. The patient relapses. The patient returns to your facility for more treatment. You bill insurance. The cycle continues untill someone dies or the government investigates.

Body brokers are paid based on patient insurance. Facilities assign dollar values to patients based on what insurance they have. A patient with a PPO policy is worth more then a patient with Medicaid. Human beings priced like commodities. The broker gets paid more for delivering “high value” patients. The incentive is to recruit patients with good insurance, not patients who need treatment.

Think about what that means for your treatment facility. Every payment to a body broker is a potential EKRA violation. Every patient referred through kickbacks creates false claims exposure. Every relapse that was engineered for billing purposes is evidence of scheme to defraud. The referral practices that seemed like normal business development were actualy federal crimes.

The Relapse Cycle That Generates Revenue

Heres something about addiction treatment fraud that exposes the dark heart of these schemes. Fraudulent facilities dont want patients to recover. They want patients to relapse.

Sober homes kept patients in a “relapse cycle.” Rather then offering treatment and support, fraudulent sober homes allow or even encourage drug use to bring clients back for treatment covered by health insurance. The patient who stays sober is a patient who stops generating revenue. The patient who relapses needs more treatment, more testing, more billing. The business model depends on failure.

The incentive structure rewards keeping patients sick. Heres the inversion that destroys treatment facilities. Legitimate rehabilitation measures success by patients who recover. Fraudulent rehabilitation measures success by patients who return. The more times a patient cycles through treatment, the more revenue they generate. The goal isnt sobriety. The goal is recurring billing.

Body brokers were paid for keeping patients “in treatment” longer. The longer a patient stayed connected to the treatment network, the more the broker got paid. The incentive was to prevent actual recovery. A recovered patient is a patient who stops generating referral payments. A patient in perpetual relapse is a patient who generates perpetual revenue.

Heres the consequence cascade that destroys everyone involved. You pay body broker. Broker pays patient cash. Patient buys drugs. Patient relapses. Patient returns for treatment. You bill insurance. Patient eventualy overdoses. Death is traced to your facility. Federal prosecution begins.

How Patients Become Commodities

Heres something about addiction treatment fraud that reveals how patients are exploited. Treatment facilities assign dollar values to human beings based on their insurance coverage.

Patients with PPO insurance are worth more. The Markovich brothers scheme involved paying kickbacks to patients through patient recruiters. Different patients had different values. The patient with comprehensive private insurance generated more revenue then the patient with basic coverage. Body brokers were paid based on the value of the patients they delivered. Human suffering converted into billing opportunities.

Some patients were worth thousands per month. As long as the patient remained connected to the treatment network, they generated recurring payments. Insurance companies paid for treatment. Testing laboratories paid kickbacks for urine samples. The treatment facility billed for services. Everyone profited except the patient trapped in a cycle designed to perpetuate their addiction.

The Kentucky sober homes scheme involved $26.7 million in urine testing fraud. Serenity Keepers, a sober home company, allegedly conspired to cause medically unnecessary urine drug tests to be fraudulently billed. The tests werent ordered becuase patients needed them. The tests were ordered becuase insurance would pay for them. Medical necessity was irrelevant. Billing potential was everything.

The Cases That Show What Happens

If you think federal addiction treatment fraud prosecutions are theoretical, look at what actualy happens to facility operators, body brokers, and everyone connected to these schemes.

Jonathan Markovich received 188 months in federal prison. His brother Daniel received 97 months. The South Florida brothers operated multiple addiction treatment facilities and orchestrated a $112 million fraud scheme. They paid kickbacks to patients through patient recruiters. They received kickbacks from testing laboratories. Combined, the brothers will serve over 23 years in federal prison.

Michael Brier received more then eight years. The owner of a Rhode Island-based chain of addiction treatment centers defrauded Medicare, Medicaid, and other health insurers out of millions. His company, Recovery Connections Centers of America, short-changed patients suffering from substance abuse disorders by failing to provide them with required counseling sessions and treatment. Patients were billed for services they never recieved.

Casey Mahoney received 41 months. The Hollywood Hills man paid $2.9 million in kickbacks to body brokers. Those brokers dropped patients at motels and introduced them to drug dealers. Some of those patients overdosed and died. The conviction arose from violations of the Eliminating Kickbacks in Recovery Act (EKRA).

Thomas Ralph Stanley received five years. He defrauded insurance companies of $141 million over two years. Five years in federal prison for a scheme that treated human addiction as a profit opportunity.

Rita Anagho pleaded guilty in a $69 million Arizona scheme. The substance abuse treatment clinic owner faced charges of conspiracy to commit health care fraud, health care fraud, money laundering, and obstruction of justice. Farrukh Ali allegedly orchestrated a $650 million fraud scheme involving 41 addiction clinics billing Arizona Medicaid for services never provided.

These arnt unusual cases. They represent standard enforcement outcomes. The sentences reach over 15 years. The schemes reach hundreds of millions of dollars. The facilites that seemed profitable collapse when investigation begins.

The Northern Ohio scheme involved $48 million in fraudulent billing. Six individuals were indicted for their roles at Braking Point Recovery Center, which operated drug and alcohol rehabilitation facilities in Ohio. Medicaid was billed for services that were not provided, not medically necessary, or lacked proper documentation. The scheme demonstrated how treatment facilities systematicaly exploit vulnerable patients while billing for services that never happened.

Scott Raffa paid $175,000 in kickbacks to body brokers. The Orange County sober living homes owner was indicted for allegedly paying illegal kickbacks for patient referrals. From April 2020 to October 2021, Raffa made 12 seperate payments totaling $174,600 to body brokers. Each payment is a seperate EKRA violation. Each violation carries up to 10 years. The kickback payments that seemed like marketing expenses become the evidence that proves criminal intent.

The Deaths That Trigger Prosecution

Heres something about addiction treatment fraud that transforms cases into devastating prosecutions. When patients die, federal prosecutors prioritize the investigation.

Patients recruited by body brokers overdosed and died. In the Mahoney case, brokered patients were dropped off at motels and introduced to drug dealers. Some of those patients later overdosed and died. The deaths connected the treatment facility to the body broker network. The deaths demonstrated the consequences of the kickback scheme. The deaths made prosecution inevitable.

Death transforms fraud into aggravated offense. Under 18 U.S.C. 1347, healthcare fraud that results in death can be punished by any term of years or life in prison. The fraud that seemed like a billing issue becomes a case where the government seeks decades of incarceration. The patient who died becomes the face of the prosecution. The jury sees a victim, not a statistic.

The relapse cycle creates death risk. Heres the consequence cascade. You encourage patients to relapse for billing purposes. Patients relapse. Patients use drugs. Patients develop tolerance. Patients seek stronger drugs. Patients overdose. Every death is traced back to your facility. The business model that generated revenue generated corpses.

Heres the uncomfortable truth about addiction treatment fraud prosecutions. When patients die, prosecutors dont offer favorable plea deals. When patients die, judges impose severe sentences. When patients die, juries convict. The scheme that seemed profitable becomes a case where everyone involved faces the maximum possible punishment.

How Addiction Treatment Investigations Begin

Heres something about how these cases develop that should concern every treatment facility operator. Investigations often begin long before anyone contacts you.

The EKRA law created new enforcement tools. The Eliminating Kickbacks in Recovery Act was enacted in 2018 as part of legislation designed to address the opioid crisis. EKRA prohibits any recovery home, clinical treatment facility, or laboratory from paying kickbacks to anybody. Each violation is punishable by up to 10 years imprisonment and a $200,000 fine. EKRA applies to private payers AND federal programs – theres no escape by avoiding Medicare.

Billing patterns trigger investigation. If your facility bills significantly more urine tests then similar providers, thats flagged. If your patient retention rates are unusualy high, thats flagged. If specific body brokers generate disproportionate referral volumes, thats flagged. The investigation starts with data.

Overdose deaths trigger mandatory reporting. When a patient dies of overdose, medical examiners investigate. Treatment history is reviewed. Recent facility admissions are identified. If the death is connected to a treatment facility with problematic practices, federal investigators become involved.

Body brokers cooperate immediatly. When body brokers are arrested, they identify every facility they sent patients to. Every kickback payment. Every cash transfer. Body brokers have no loyalty to facilities – they cooperate to reduce their own exposure. You may become a target becuase a body broker you paid was arrested and named you.

What You Cannot Do When Investigated

Heres what people do when they learn about addiction treatment fraud investigations. They panic. They try to fix things. They make decisions that create additional criminal exposure.

Do NOT destroy or alter patient records. Treatment documentation, billing files, contracts with body brokers, payment records to patient recruiters. Destroying any of this is obstruction of justice. The government probly already has copies through insurance claims data and records seized from body brokers. Destruction proves consciousness of guilt.

Do NOT contact body brokers or patient recruiters to coordinate stories. If you paid kickbacks for patient referrals, your natural instinct is to talk to those you paid. Dont. Coordinating testimony is witness tampering. They may already be cooperating with the government. Your conversation could be recorded.

Do NOT continue questionable referral practices. If your recieving patients through body broker networks, stop. But dont try to “clean up” by restructuring contracts or creating backdated documentation. Thats additional fraud.

Do NOT assume cooperation will protect you. Treatment facility operators often think full cooperation will result in leniency. Cooperation might help at sentencing if your convicted. But it dosent prevent prosecution. When patients die, prosecutors dont negotiate. You need an attorney before you say anything.

The EKRA Math

Heres something about addiction treatment fraud that exponentialy increases legal exposure. EKRA penalties apply per violation – and every kickback payment is a seperate violation.

How the EKRA multiplier works. You pay a body broker for each patient referral. Each payment is a seperate EKRA violation. Each violation carries up to 10 years imprisonment and a $200,000 fine. If you paid for 100 patient referrals, you face 100 potential violations. At 10 years per violation, thats a theoretical maximum of 1,000 years.

The laboratory kickback compounds the exposure. Many schemes involve receiving kickbacks from testing laboratories. The facility sends patient samples to the lab. The lab bills insurance. The lab pays kickback to facility. Each kickback payment is a seperate violation. The referral kickback plus the laboratory kickback creates dual exposure for every patient.

False Claims Act liability stacks on top. Every claim submitted based on kickback arrangements is potentialy a false claim. Each false claim carries penalties of up to $27,894. Plus treble damages. Plus restitution. The EKRA criminal exposure plus the False Claims Act civil exposure creates financial devastation.

The DOJ Sober Homes Initiative demonstrates the scale of enforcement. In its first year, the initiative charged defendants in connection with over $845 million in allegedly false and fraudulent claims. The National Rapid Response Strike Force, Miami Strike Force, and Los Angeles Strike Force lead the initiative. Federal resources are dedicated specificaly to prosecuting addiction treatment fraud. The schemes that operated for years are being systematicaly dismantled.

Civil monetary penalties compound the criminal exposure. The Office of Inspector General can pursue civil penalties seperate from criminal prosecution. Up to $100,000 per kickback under the Civil Monetary Penalties Law. Plus treble damages. Plus permanent exclusion from federal healthcare programs. Even if you avoid prison, the civil liability can bankrupt you. Even if you keep your freedom, you lose the ability to operate any facility that bills federal programs.

What You Should Do Right Now

If federal investigators have contacted you about addiction treatment billing, or if your referral practices might trigger scrutiny, heres exactly what you should do:

Contact a federal healthcare fraud defense attorney immediatly. Not a general business lawyer. Not your malpractice carrier. Someone who specificaly handles federal healthcare fraud cases and understands EKRA enforcement.

Do NOT speak to investigators without counsel. Federal agents may approach you or your staff for “voluntary” interviews. There is nothing voluntary about it. Anything said can be used to build the case against you. Politely decline and contact an attorney immediatly.

Preserve all documentation exactly as it is. Patient records, billing files, contracts with body brokers, referral agreements, payment records. Do not alter, destroy, or organize anything. Document preservation is critical.

Identify all potentially problematic referral sources. Body broker relationships. Patient recruiter arrangements. Laboratory kickbacks. Any payments connected to patient volume. Your attorney needs to understand the full scope.

Do NOT discuss the investigation with staff, body brokers, or referral sources. Anyone you talk to can be compelled to testify. They may already be cooperating with the government. Only attorney-client communications are protected.

Todd Spodek tells every treatment facility operator in this situation the same thing: federal addiction treatment fraud investigations are serious criminal matters. Jonathan Markovich got 188 months. Michael Brier got eight years. Patients overdosed and died. Your response in the next few days could determine wheather this becomes a matter that resolves favorably – or federal charges that destroy your facility and your freedom.

Call Spodek Law Group at 212-300-5196. Before you speak to investigators. Before you make decisions that create additional exposure. Before a body broker arrangement becomes a federal prosecution.

Federal addiction treatment fraud is an enforcement priority. The sentences reach decades. What you do next matters enormosly.