Criminal Defense Lawyers

Federal Home Health Care Fraud – What You Need to Know

Federal Home Health Care Fraud – What You Need to Know

Federal agents just showed up at your home health agency. Or you received a target letter from the Department of Justice. Or a former employee told you that investigators have been asking questions about your billing practices. Your first instinct might be to think this is some kind of misunderstanding – you provide real care to real patients, your staff works hard. Heres the first thing you need to understand: home health care fraud prosecutions dont require proof that you failed to provide care. You can be convicted for billing services that were actualy provided if those services werent medically necessary or if patients didnt qualify. A Houston-area doctor recieved 25 years in federal prison for selling false medical certifications. Faith Newton recieved 12 years for stealing $100 million from MassHealth. These arnt theoretical outcomes.

Welcome to Spodek Law Group. We handle federal healthcare fraud defense cases regularly, including cases were home health agency owners first realize theyre facing serious criminal exposure through exactly this kind of contact. The second thing you need to understand is this: home health care has become a priority target for federal enforcement. In 2024 alone, the Department of Justice charged 193 defendants in a single nationwide healthcare fraud action. The alleged false claims exceeded $2.75 billion. The government seized $231 million in assets. Federal prosecutors view home health as a fraud-prone industry – and theyre aggressivly pursuing criminal charges.

Heres something most home health agency owners dont realize about this industry. An estimated 69% of the population will need home caregiving services at some point. That vulnerable population makes home health enormosly attractive to fraudsters – and makes the government enormosly aggressive in enforcement. The Medicare Fraud Strike Force operates in 23 federal districts with 14 strike forces. Since 2007, the Health Care Fraud Unit has charged more then 5,400 defendants who collectively billed more than $27 billion. Home health agencies are disproportionately represented in those prosecutions.

The Schemes That Send People to Prison

Heres the uncomfortable truth about home health care fraud. The schemes that result in federal prison sentences often involve real patients receiving real services. The fraud is in the documentation, the medical necessity, or the qualification status – not necessarily in whether care was actualy provided.

Billing for services not performed is the most straightforward form of fraud. Staff members clock in for visits that never happen. Documentation is copy-pasted from previous visits. The agency bills Medicare for services that exist only on paper. Faith Newton’s scheme involved creating falsified copy-and-paste notes from nursing visits that didnt happen. She got 12 years.

Billing for medically unnecessary services is more insidious. The patients are real. The visits happen. But the patients dont actualy qualify for home health services under Medicare rules. The certifications that made them eligible were false. Every claim becomes a fraudulent claim – even though care was actualy provided.

Falsifying the homebound requirement catches many agencies. Medicare requires patients to be homebound to qualify for home health services. Patients who can leave home for medical appointments or occasional events might still qualify. But patients who regularly leave home for non-medical reasons dont qualify. Billing for patients who arnt actualy homebound is fraud – even if they received excellent care.

Think about what that means for your agency. You might genuinly beleive your patients qualify. Your staff might be providing genuine care. But if the documentation supporting medical necessity is inadequate or inaccurate, every claim becomes a false claim. The paradox is brutal: providing actual care to real patients can still be federal healthcare fraud.

The Patient Recruiter Problem

Heres something about home health care that creates massive criminal exposure. The way many agencies find patients is itself a federal crime.

Patient recruiters are paid to find Medicare beneficiaries. They approach seniors at community centers, churches, health fairs. They cold-call from Medicare beneficiary lists. They offer incentives to sign up for home health services. Then they sell the patient information to home health agencies. This is a kickback scheme – and everyone involved faces federal charges.

One patient recruiter recruited over 4,000 Medicare beneficiaries for multiple home health companies across the country. Employees were instructed to cold call Medicare beneficiaries and offer incentives to induce them to sign up. They then sold the beneficiary information to home health agencies in exchange for illegal kickback payments.

Carlos Rodriguez Nerey was convicted for his role in a patient recruitment fraud scheme. He created a shell company for accepting kickbacks and recieved approximately $250,000. Medicare paid more then $2 million for the fraudulent claims connected to beneficiaries he recruited.

Heres the irony that should disturb every home health agency owner. Patient recruiters are often presented as marketing services – helping you find patients who need care. In reality, theyre kickback conduits. Paying per patient for referrals is a federal crime under the Anti-Kickback Statute. The recruiter faces charges. The agency that paid them faces charges. Everyone in the chain faces federal prosecution.

The Kickback Arrangements That Create Liability

Heres something about home health operations that creates enormous criminal exposure. The relationships that bring patients to your agency may be illegal kickback arrangements.

Noli and Isabel Tcruz operated a home health care company in Michigan. They engaged in a $5 million conspiracy to pay kickbacks and bribes to acquire referrals for Medicare beneficiaries. Noli recieved 6 years in federal prison. Isabel recieved 38 months. Two physicians who accepted kickbacks from them were required to pay more than $3 million in restitution.

The scheme worked like many do. Pay recruiters to find patients. Pay physicians to certify those patients as eligible. Bill Medicare for services. Everyone gets paid. Everyone goes to prison.

Felix Maduka operated Joystar Home Health Services in Texas. He structured over $1.8 million in cash withdrawals to conceal a $4.5 million healthcare fraud scheme. He recieved 5 years in federal prison. The structuring charges – trying to hide the money – added to his sentence.

Heres the hidden connection most agency owners miss. Every payment you make to find patients is potentialy a kickback. Every relationship with a physician who certifies your patients is potentialy a kickback arrangement. The Anti-Kickback Statute prohibits paying anything of value to induce referrals. The “one purpose” rule means that if kickbacks were even ONE purpose of the payment – among other legitimate purposes – you violated the law.

The Cases That Show What Happens

If you think home health fraud prosecutions are theoretical, look at what actualy happens to agency owners.

Faith Newton operated Arbor Homecare Services in Massachusetts. From 2013 to 2017, she stole at least $100 million from MassHealth. The scheme involved billing for services never provided, falsifying documentation, paying kickbacks for referrals, and creating sham employment relationships with patients’ family members. The judge noted she did it “with the sole purpose of funding her lavish lifestyle.” She recieved 12 years in federal prison.

Marianna Levin owned a Brooklyn-based home health agency. She billed tens of millions to Medicaid for services that were not actualy rendered. She was sentenced to 54 months in federal prison, ordered to forfeit $1.5 million, and ordered to pay restitution of $36.3 million. She will never be able to repay that amount.

Paul Njoku operated a home health agency in Houston. He was convicted on all counts for leading a Medicare fraud scheme involving falsified medical records. The jury heard testimony that Njoku forged signatures of doctors and nurses. The jury deliberated for less then two hours after a three-day trial. He recieved 75 months in federal prison.

A Detroit-area home healthcare owner recieved 84 months in federal prison for paying illegal kickbacks for patient referrals and billing Medicare for services not rendered or medically necessary. She was ordered to pay more then $8 million in restitution.

These arnt unusual cases. They represent standard enforcement outcomes. The prison sentences are substantial. The restitution orders are crushing. The consequences extend far beyond the criminal case itself.

How Home Health Fraud Investigations Begin

Heres something about how these cases develop that should concern every agency owner. Investigations often begin long before anyone contacts you.

Medicare data analytics identify suspicious billing patterns. Your claims are compared against statistical norms. If your agency bills significantly more per patient then similar agencies, thats flagged. If your visit patterns deviate from typical care, thats flagged. If your certification rates are unusual, thats flagged. The investigation starts with data – before anyone visits your office.

Whistleblowers have massive financial incentive to report. Under the False Claims Act qui tam provisions, whistleblowers can receive 15-30% of government recoveries. Your billing staff, your nurses, your aides – anyone who sees something questionable has powerful financial motivation to report it. A single nurse who reports billing irregularities could receive millions.

Cooperating defendants name everyone involved. When the government investigates patient recruiters, those recruiters identify every agency they worked with. When they investigate physicians who signed certifications, those physicians identify every agency that paid them. You may become a target because someone else’s investigation led to your name.

Heres the consequence cascade. You pay a recruiter to find patients. Years later, that recruiter is investigated. The recruiter cooperates and provides records of every agency they worked with. Your agency is on the list. Now youre a target. The investigation that started with someone else ends with federal charges against you.

The Form 485 That Creates Criminal Liability

Heres something about home health documentation that creates specific criminal exposure. The physician certification of medical necessity – CMS Form 485 – is the foundation of every home health billing claim.

Form 485 certifies that a patient is homebound and needs skilled care. A physician must sign it. That signature represents that the physician has evaluated the patient and determined they qualify for home health services. Every subsequent claim depends on that certification being accurate.

If Form 485 is false, every claim is fraudulent. If the patient wasnt actualy homebound. If they didnt actualy need skilled nursing care. If the physician signed without actualy evaluating the patient. Every single claim submitted based on that certification becomes a false claim.

The Houston-area doctor who recieved 25 years was convicted for selling false medical certificates to home health companies. He never saw the patients. He just signed certifications for payment. The home health companies used those certifications to bill Medicare for unnecessary and nonexistent procedures. His sentence is effectively a life term.

Think about what that means for your agency. Every Form 485 is a potential criminal charge. If your certifying physicians are signing without properly evaluating patients, youre building a fraud case against yourself. If youre paying physicians anything connected to those certifications, youre creating kickback liability. The documentation that makes your business possible is the documentation that can send you to prison.

What You Cannot Do When Investigated

Heres what home health agency owners do when they learn about investigations. They panic. They try to fix things. They make decisions that create additional criminal exposure.

Do NOT destroy or alter documentation. Patient records, billing records, employee records, contracts with recruiters or physicians. Destroying any of this is obstruction of justice. The government probly already has copies through Medicare claims data. Destruction proves consciousness of guilt while accomplishing nothing.

Do NOT contact recruiters, physicians, or others to coordinate stories. If you paid kickbacks to patient recruiters or certifying physicians, your natural instinct is to talk to them about the investigation. Dont. Coordinating testimony is witness tampering. They may already be cooperating with the government. Your conversation could be recorded.

Do NOT continue questionable billing practices. If youre billing for services you know are problematic, your instinct might be to stop. Thats correct. But dont try to “clean up” by backdating documentation or creating records that didnt exist. Thats additional fraud.

Do NOT assume cooperation will protect you. Agency owners often think full cooperation will result in leniency. Cooperation might help at sentencing if youre convicted. But it dosent prevent prosecution. Everything you say to investigators can be used against you. You need an attorney before you say anything.

The False Claims Act Multiplier

Heres something about home health fraud that exponentialy increases legal exposure. Every fraudulent certification triggers False Claims Act liability for EVERY claim connected to that patient.

How the multiplier works. A patient is incorrectly certified as homebound. Every visit billed for that patient becomes a false claim. Each false claim carries penalties of up to $27,894 (as of 2024). Plus treble damages – three times the government’s loss. A patient receiving weekly visits for two years generates over 100 false claims from a single bad certification.

The exposure compounds across your patient population. If your agency has systemic documentation problems, every patient file becomes a source of False Claims Act liability. Hundreds of patients with problematic certifications means thousands of false claims. The math quickly reaches tens of millions in potential exposure.

Marianna Levin was ordered to pay $36.3 million in restitution. That number reflects the False Claims Act multiplier applied to years of billing. The original scheme might have involved millions – but the False Claims Act exposure was crushing. She will never be able to pay that amount. It will follow her for the rest of her life.

Heres the uncomfortable truth about False Claims Act exposure. Individual kickbacks or certification problems might seem manageable. A few thousand dollars here, a questionable patient there. But the False Claims Act transforms every connected claim into seperate liability. What seems like limited exposure becomes financial devastation.

The Whistleblower Incentive Problem

Heres something about home health enforcement that agency owners dont fully appreciate. The people most likely to report you work for you.

Employees see everything problematic. Your billing staff knows when documentation is fabricated. Your nurses know which patients arnt really homebound. Your aides know when visits are logged but never occur. Any of them can file a qui tam lawsuit and potentially receive millions.

The qui tam process protects whistleblowers. They file under seal. The government investigates for months or years before you know. By the time you learn about the investigation, the government may have already gathered extensive evidence. Your former employee is protected by whistleblower laws and stands to receive 15-30% of whatever the government recovers.

Think about what that means. A disgruntled employee who left your agency has financial incentive to report any irregularities they witnessed. The qui tam lawsuit process rewards them for doing so. Assuming loyalty will protect you is dangerously naive.

The Exclusion That Ends Everything

Heres something about healthcare fraud convictions that home health agency owners need to understand. Federal conviction triggers mandatory exclusion from Medicare, Medicaid, and all federal healthcare programs.

Exclusion means your agency cannot bill federal programs. In home health care, where Medicare and Medicaid represent the vast majority of revenue, exclusion effectively closes your business. You cannot provide services to federal program beneficiaries. Your business model disappears.

Individual exclusion follows you personally. Even if you close the agency, you cannot work for any entity that bills federal healthcare programs. You cannot start a new agency. You cannot work for another provider. Your career in healthcare is effectively over.

The punishment extends far beyond the prison sentence. You serve your time. You pay your fines. But you still cant work in healthcare because youre excluded. Even a favorable resolution that avoids prison might still result in exclusion that ends your career.

What You Should Do Right Now

If federal investigators have contacted your home health agency, or if you have billing practices that might trigger scrutiny, heres exactly what you should do:

Contact a federal healthcare fraud defense attorney immediatly. Not a general business lawyer. Not your regulatory compliance consultant. Someone who specificaly handles federal healthcare fraud cases and understands how these investigations become prosecutions.

Do NOT speak to investigators without counsel. Federal agents may approach you or your staff for “voluntary” interviews. There is nothing voluntary about it. Anything said can be used to build the case against you. Politely decline and contact an attorney immediatly.

Preserve all documentation exactly as it is. Patient files, billing records, Form 485 certifications, contracts with recruiters or physicians, financial records. Do not alter, destroy, or organize anything. Document preservation is critical.

Identify all potential exposure areas. Patient recruitment relationships. Physician certification arrangements. Billing patterns that might look unusual. Staff who might have concerns. Your attorney needs to understand the full scope.

Do NOT discuss the investigation with staff, recruiters, or physicians. Anyone you talk to can be compelled to testify. They may already be cooperating with the government. Only attorney-client communications are protected.

Todd Spodek tells every home health agency owner in this situation the same thing: federal healthcare fraud investigations are serious criminal matters. Faith Newton got 12 years. A Houston doctor got 25 years. Paul Njoku got 75 months after a jury deliberated less then two hours. Your response in the next few days could determine wheather this becomes a matter that resolves favorably – or federal charges that destroy your business and your freedom.

Call Spodek Law Group at 212-300-5196. Before you speak to investigators. Before you make decisions that create additional exposure. Before a billing question becomes a federal prosecution.

Home health care is a federal enforcement priority. What you do next matters enormosly.