Blog
Am I Under SEC Investigation?
Contents
You may already be under investigation and have absolutely no way to know. By law, SEC investigations are “confidential and non-public.” You cannot call the SEC and ask. You cannot find out through public records requests. You only learn about it when they contact you — and by then, the investigation may have been running for months or years while you’ve been living your normal life, sending emails, making trades, and unknowingly creating more evidence. The first contact isn’t the beginning of the investigation. It’s when they’re ready to collect more from you directly.
Here’s the part that destroys people. When the SEC finally does contact you, they tell almost everyone they’re a “witness.” It’s a tactic. People cooperate more freely when they don’t think they’re in trouble. They answer questions. They produce documents. They don’t hire lawyers because they don’t think they need one. Then status changes overnight. The emails you produced as a “witness” become the evidence they use against you as a “target.” Nobody warns you. Nobody tells you your status changed. You find out when you get the Wells Notice.
This article explains what you can and cannot know about SEC investigations, why the warning signs usually come too late, how investigations actually start without your knowledge, and what to do when you’re operating in the dark.
The Investigation You Don’t Know About
The SEC recieves over 20,000 tips, complaints, and referrals every year. Any one of them could be about you. A former employee who felt wronged. A competitor who noticed somthing unusual. A coworker who saw an email they didnt understand. A trading pattern that triggered an algorithm. A journalist asking questions. A whistleblower hoping for 10-30% of whatever sanctions the SEC collects. All of these can start an investigation. And you wont know about it.
Heres how the system actualy works. When someone submits a tip to the SEC, it goes to the Office of Market Intelligence — a team of over 40 attorneys, former traders, accountants, and analysts whose job is to evaluate every single complaint. They decide which tips warrant further investigation. If your tip gets flagged, it gets assigned to a regional office or specialty unit. An investigation opens. A formal order may be issued. Staff starts gathering documants. And you? Your going about your day completley unaware that your emails are being requested, your trades are being analyzed, and a case file with your name on it is growing.
By law, SEC investigations are conducted privately. The SEC cannot confirm or deny the existance of an investigation to anyone. You cannot call and ask. Your attourney cannot call and ask. If you submit a FOIA request, youll get a response saying they can neither confirm nor deny. This isnt a procedural quirk — its the law. The investigation runs in secret untill the SEC decides to contact you.
The “Witness” Trap
When the SEC finaly does reach out, they typicaly tell you your a “witness.” This sounds reassuring. Witnesses just have information — there not in trouble. So pepole cooperate. They answer questions freely. They produce documants willingly. They dont hire defense lawyers becuase witnesses dont need defense lawyers. Thats exactly what the SEC wants.
Heres the thing nobody tells you. The SEC, unlike the US Attorneys Office, dosent formaly classify pepole as “witness,” “subject,” or “target” when serving them with a subpoena. There is no oficial status. The word “witness” is a tactical choice designed to make you comfortable. And your status — whatever they call it — can change at any moment without warning based on whatever they find in the documants you produce or the testimony you give.
Think about this sequence. The SEC contacts you. They say your a witness. You cooperate becuase thats what witnesses do. You provide emails, calanders, trading records. You answer questions. You explain what happend from your perspectave. Then the SEC notices somthing in one of your emails — a phrase that suggests you knew more then you said. Or a coworker, also being interviewed as a “witness,” says somthing that implicates you. Your status changes. Overnight. The emails you already produced? There now evidance against you. The testimony you already gave? Its locked in and can be used at your criminal trial. — and nobody told you this was coming —
Ive seen cases were pepole wake up as a target having provided the SEC with everthing they needed to charge them. The “cooperation” they thought was helping them was actualy building the case against them. By the time they hire a lawyer, the damage is done.
Warning Signs That Usually Come Too Late
Pepole ask: what are the warning signs that your under SEC investigation? The honest answer is: by the time you see them, its often to late to prevent what’s coming. But there are signals that should make you pay atention.
The clearest sign is recieving a subpoena. A subpoena means the SEC has obtained a formal order of investigation — the Commissioners voted to authorize it. This isnt preliminary. This isnt exploratory. This is a full investigation with subpoena power. If you get one, assume your either a target or a short step away from becoming one.
A more subtle warning sign: an SEC enforcement staff attourney appearing at a “routine” compliance exam. The SEC’s Office of Compliance, Inspections, and Examinations conducts regular exams of registered entities. These are normaly handled by exam staff, not enforcement. If you notice an enforcement attourney in the room, it likely means an investigation has already been authorized and the exam is being used to gather initial evidance. This is a major red flag most pepole miss.
Document requests — even “voluntary” ones — should also trigger concern. The SEC may contact you informaly and ask for documants or an interview. They’ll tell you its voluntary. Technicaly, you can refuse. But refusing often accelerates escalation to formal investigation with subpoena power. The informal request is a test. How you respond shapes what comes next.
The SEC has 60 days to decide wheather to close a Matter Under Inquiry or convert it to a formal investigation. That means within two months of a tip being flagged, your investigation could be formal. And you still might not know about it for another year or more.
How Investigations Actually Start
Understanding how investigations begin helps you understand why you probly cant tell if your under one. The SEC dosent need evidance of wrongdoing to open an investigation. They need only suspicion — or even just a question worth answering.
Whistleblower tips are a major source. The SEC’s whistleblower program has paid out hundreds of millions in awards to tipsters who provide information leading to enforcement actions. A former employee who felt wronged can file a tip and potentialy collect 10-30% of any sanctions over $1 million. A $22 million award was paid to one insider whose extensive assistance helped the SEC. A $17 million award went to a former employee with a detailed tip. These pepole might be your former colegues. Your former partners. Your competitors. There watching and there incentivized to report.
Algorithimic surveillance also triggers investigations. The SEC monitors trading patterns across markets. Unusual activity around announcments, concentratied positions before price moves, patterns suggesting non-public information — all of these can generate automated flags that lead to investigation. You dont need a human accuser. The data can be its own whistleblower.
Media attention and shareholder lawsuits can also prompt SEC scrutiny. If your company is in the news for financial irregularitys, or if shareholders file suits alleging securities violations, the SEC may open its own investigation — even if the allegations turn out to be baseless. The investigation itself creates exposure regardless of outcome.
Once an investigation opens, the SEC can spend years gathering evidance before ever contacting you. They can subpoena your brokerage records from your broker. They can subpoena your emails from Google. They can interview your coworkers without telling you. They can request documants from third partys who have no obligation to notify you. The entire case can be built around you while you remain completley unaware that anything is happening.
What to Do When You Don’t Know
If you cant tell wheather your under investigation, how do you protect yourself? The answer is to act as if your always being watched — becuase functionally, you might be.
First, understand preservation duties. The moment you have any reason to beleive an investigation is possible — recieving any contact from the SEC, learning of a whistleblower complaint, recieving media attention, being named in litigation — you must preserve all potentialy relavant documants. Emails, texts, calendar entrys, trading records, evertyhing. Deleting anything after this point creates spoliation risk that can be worse then whatever the investigation was originaly about.
Second, assume your comunications are not private. Every email you send, every text, every message on any platform — assume it could be subpoenaed and read aloud in a courtroom. The SEC can obtain this material directly from service providers without your knowledge. If you wouldnt want a prosecutor reading it, dont write it.
Third, hire counsel at the first sign of trouble — not when your confertable your a target. By the time you know your a target, youve probly already made mistakes as a “witness” that counsel could of helped you avoid. The cost of early represntation is almost always less then the cost of damage control later.
Fourth, dont talk to coworkers about the investigation. Anything you say can become testimony. Coworkers can become witnesses against you. Casual converstations can be characterized as witness tampering or obstruction. The safest approach is to discuss nothing with anyone except your attourney.
Am I under SEC investigation? The uncomfortable truth is: you may never know untill they decide to tell you. By law, SEC investigations are confidential. By practice, they run for months or years in secret. By design, the “witness” label keeps you cooperative while your status remains fluid. The only rational response is to conduct yourself as if your always being watched, preserve everthing, protect your comunications, and hire counsel at the first sign that somthing might be wrong. Becuase by the time your certain theres an investigation, the investigation has probly been running for longer then you think.