Last Updated on: 26th July 2023, 10:55 pm

Unlawful imprisonment refers to detaining someone without any legal authority or against that person’s will. It occurs when an individual prevents a person from leaving a room, vehicle, house or any other area. There are two types of unlawful imprisonment in New York Penal Law. The first one involves unlawful imprisonment in the first degree. The other one is unlawful imprisonment in the second degree. A person is said to be guilty of unlawful imprisonment in the first degree when he restrains someone under circumstances that expose the latter to the risk of a serious physical harm. Unlawful imprisonment in the first degree is a class E felony and attracts up to four years in prison. The word restrain in the Penal Law is defined as intentionally and unlawfully retracting the movement of another person against his will.

Example of Unlawful Imprisonment in the First Degree

Ruth, a resident of Manhattan, went to a club on a Friday evening to relax after a long week of hard work. While she was sitting alone at the corner of the restaurant, a young man approached him. His name was Donald. He introduced himself and the two quickly got used to each other. They talked for several hours, joking and laughing about their workmates and life. Donald then invited Ruth to accompany him to his house and she agreed. They arrived at the house, cooked some food and watched a movie. Ruth woke up early the next morning and told Donald she wanted to go back to her house. Donald quickly locked the door and told her to stay until Monday. Ruth did not agree and decided to force herself out. Donald reached for a gun and threatened to shoot her if she persisted. Ruth waited until Donald was in the bathroom and jumped out though the balcony, injuring herself in the process.

This is a classic case of unlawful imprisonment in the first degree. Donald could be charged with wrongfully detaining Ruth and causing her to sustain injuries.

Defenses to the penal code

A prosecutor must show that you indeed imprisoned someone without his or her will and that the person was actually unable to leave. The prosecutor will do some research on his own to determine the facts surrounding the incident. This may involve interviewing the victim to get his side of the story or requesting for surveillance footage of the place.

There are many ways you can defend yourself against such accusations. For instance, if you locked someone in a room with an open window, you may have a valid defense against a charge of unlawful detention. You can also defend yourself by convincing the judge that the victim was not in any danger of a serious physical injury at that time. For example, if you pointed a gun at the person to prevent him from leaving, but the gun was actually a toy, you may have some valid defense.

Hiring a Lawyer

Defending yourself against unlawful imprisonment charge is your basic right. However, it is unwise to go at it alone due to several legal risks and obstacles present. You need to hire a NYC criminal lawyer to help protect your rights and create a strong defense. A lawyer has studied and trained in understanding every aspect of criminal law in New York. He knows the right approach to take to help you win the case and protect you against heavy penalties.

Before you hire a lawyer, make sure he has several years of experience dealing with unlawful imprisonment cases. Also, make sure he has a high rate of success in his works.

New York Penal Law 135.05: Unlawful imprisonment in the second degree

In New York, it is illegal to purposely restrain another person. When you restrain somebody else even though you don’t have the legal right to, you are committing unlawful imprisonment, which is a crime. Even if you are not particularly violent towards the person, you can still be charged with unlawful imprisonment in the second degree. Typically, unlawful imprisonment includes a physical restraint – locking a person in a room or tying them to a piece of furniture, for example.

Defining Restraint

According to New York law, the word “restrain” refers to when a person’s movements are restricted so that they cannot move from one place to another. This can include confining the person or forcing them to move to another location where they are also restricted. Though physical force is sometimes used, it doesn’t have to be present. The victim may be intimated or deceived instead of hurt or handled physically. To fully understand how “restrain” is defined in New York, refer to penal law § 135.00(1), which discusses the intentional and unlawful restriction of a person.

Example of Unlawful Imprisonment in the Second Degree

Mike breaks into the house of a stranger, intending to rob it when nobody is home. While he is searching the house for items to take, the owner of the home returns. Mike takes the owner of the home, pushes him into a bedroom and ties him to a chair. He then shuts the bedroom door behind him and moves a big piece of furniture in front of it so he can’t get out. Mike then leaves the house. Since he prevented the owner from leaving the bedroom, Mike can be charged with unlawful imprisonment in the second degree.

Unlawful Imprisonment Sentence

Unlawful imprisonment in the second degree is considered a class A misdemeanor. This crime comes with a maximum sentence of one year in jail. As an alternative to jail time, the judge may opt for a sentence of three years of probation.

Defenses Against Unlawful Imprisonment in the Second Degree

If you are dealing with an unlawful imprisonment charge, a NYC criminal lawyer can help. It’s possible that your defense will be that the person was not truly restrained. If the person should have been able to get out of the restraint, your defense may be that the person could have escaped with just a little bit of effort. Even if the person did not escape, if it was possible that they could, your lawyer may be able to argue that defense.

Related Offenses

Related offenses are unlawful imprisonment in the first degree and kidnapping in both the first and second degree. The language between these offenses can be similar, which is why it requires a professional criminal attorney to assess the nuances of your case. For example, the primary difference between a kidnapping charge and an unlawful imprisonment charge is the word “abduct.” In kidnapping, an abduction occurs, while in unlawful imprisonment, restraint, not abduction, occurs. If you’re being charged with kidnapping even though you should be charged with unlawful imprisonment in the second degree, you’ll want a criminal lawyer to work on your behalf.

If you’ve been charged with unlawful imprisonment, it’s important to contact a criminal attorney right away. Legal guidance is necessary in order to maximize your options and reduce your sentence as much as possible.

Understanding Unlawful Imprisonment: Types, Examples, and Defenses

Unlawful imprisonment is the shocking and unjust act of detaining someone without any legal authority or against that person’s will. It occurs when an individual prevents a person from leaving a room, vehicle, house, or any other area. In New York Penal Law, there are two types of unlawful imprisonment:

1. Unlawful Imprisonment in the First Degree

A person is said to be guilty of unlawful imprisonment in the first degree when they restrain someone under circumstances that expose the latter to the risk of serious physical harm. This is a class E felony and attracts up to four years in prison.

Example of Unlawful Imprisonment in the First Degree:

Ruth, a hardworking resident of Manhattan, went to a club on a Friday evening to relax. While sitting alone in the corner of the restaurant, a young man named Donald approached her. They talked for several hours, laughing about their workmates and life. Donald then invited Ruth to his house, and she agreed. But when Ruth woke up the next morning and wanted to leave, Donald locked the door and threatened her with a gun. Ruth jumped out of the balcony to escape, injuring herself in the process.

This is a classic case of unlawful imprisonment in the first degree. Donald could be charged with wrongful detention and causing injury to Ruth.

2. Unlawful Imprisonment in the Second Degree

In this type, a person restrains another unlawfully and intentionally, without causing serious physical harm. This is a class A misdemeanor, with a maximum sentence of one year in jail or three years of probation.

Example of Unlawful Imprisonment in the Second Degree:

Mike breaks into a stranger’s house intending to rob it. When the owner returns home, Mike ties him to a chair in a bedroom and blocks the door with furniture. As he prevented the owner from leaving the room, Mike can be charged with unlawful imprisonment in the second degree.

Legal Defenses Against Unlawful Imprisonment Charges

It is crucial to hire a skilled NYC criminal lawyer to help create a strong defense and protect your rights. Defending yourself against unlawful imprisonment charges is your basic right, but going at it alone can expose you to legal risks and obstacles.

Valid defenses against such accusations may include arguing that:

• The victim was not in any danger of serious physical injury at the time
• The victim was not truly restrained or could have escaped with just a little effort

Related Offenses: Unlawful Imprisonment and Kidnapping

Unlawful imprisonment in the first degree is related to kidnapping in both the first and second degree. The key difference between kidnapping and unlawful imprisonment charges lies in the term “abduct”. In kidnapping, an abduction occurs, while in unlawful imprisonment, only restraint takes place.

If you are facing charges that should be for unlawful imprisonment instead of kidnapping, you will need a seasoned criminal lawyer to work diligently on your behalf, assessing the nuances of your case.

The Importance of Consulting a Criminal Attorney

If you have been charged with unlawful imprisonment, it is imperative to contact a criminal attorney right away. Legal guidance is necessary to maximize your options, reduce your sentence as much as possible, and ensure you can navigate the complex legal waters with confidence.