How to Restructure Business Debt Without Bankruptcy
Delancey Street
Important: Delancey Street is not a law firm. They are a business debt and MCA settlement company that works with a nationwide network of licensed attorneys, and those attorneys are the ones who negotiate with your funder, raise legal defenses in court when a case gets there, and close settlements at 30-60% of the outstanding balance. The distinction matters in practice, because when counsel from that network calls a funder, the funder is dealing with someone who can make the file expensive.
They have settled over $100M in business debt. The attorney network handles the whole sequence: stopping the daily ACH debits, challenging UCC liens, answering lawsuits, and drafting settlement agreements that carry full releases and UCC-3 terminations. Most single-position files resolve in 2 to 8 weeks. No upfront fees, and they work in all 50 states.
National Debt Relief
Important: National Debt Relief is not a law firm, and they do not handle MCA-specific litigation, confession-of-judgment challenges, or UCC lien disputes. What they are is the largest debt settlement company in the United States, with an A+ Better Business Bureau rating and more than 550,000 clients served. Where they fit is the debt sitting alongside your advances: credit cards, vendor accounts, and lines of credit.
CuraDebt
Important: CuraDebt is not a law firm and does not litigate MCA cases. They have spent 25 years on business debt and IRS and state tax resolution, which matters more than it sounds like it should, because a business that fell behind on advances has usually fallen behind on payroll taxes too, and forgiven debt can land as taxable income. They are IAPDA certified.
It seems natural to think Chapter 11 is the first thing to do when you own a failing company. It isn’t. Bankruptcy should be the last resort. Out-of-court restructuring or liquidation can return more to stakeholders for less cost while avoiding the bad publicity that comes with bankruptcy. That bad publicity can really hurt a turnaround. In an out-of-court turnaround, you gradually give yourself some breathing room by talking to each key creditor or vendor individually and cutting deals with them to get some more time. This article talks through how that works, and shows why this is true.
The techniques in this article apply in almost any industry and any type of company. Debtors may be manufacturers, retailers, or service companies. Secured creditors can include banks with credit lines secured by the debtors’ receivables, inventory, equipment, and real estate. On top of the bank are unpaid trade creditors, usually a combination of vendors, landlords, and equipment lessors. The bank might have been current until recently, or the bank loan may be slightly behind. Covenants often will have been broken. The failing business owes money to everyone important.
Keep Operating or Not
The first decision you make when a company runs out of money is whether the entity should keep operating or not. The decision isn’t always obvious, even if there are some obvious facts to help you decide. One factor to consider, of course, is whether the debtor has any chance at long-term viability, and that starts with whether there’s a market for the stuff you’re selling. Without a market for the company’s products and services the company will never get back on its feet. Keeping it going is just throwing good money after bad. Deciding to liquidate is just deciding to move on to Plan B. Sometimes there is a competitor that will buy the business at a distressed price and acquire a few customers. If not, then it’s time to quickly wind down. In either case, you’ll want to bring in an independent turnaround professional to lend credibility when asking creditors for concessions.
If the owners have personal guarantees, they want as much money as possible returned to creditors. Some owners will react irrationally, but most people want to do well for as many people as they can. A business doesn’t need to show profits to survive; it needs to break even. Selling as a going concern works best when the business is near cash break even. Potential buyers will have more confidence about the stability of the business if it’s been stable for a while. If you can’t do that for 90 days, the business has to shut down.
A Viable Plan to Turn the Company Around
If there’s still a market for what you’re doing, then you’ll need a viable plan to turn the company around. Business planning usually comes in two stages.
Stage one of a turnaround comes during the crisis. You’re still paying your ongoing costs (for things like payroll, payroll taxes, rent, utilities, and any core supplies), but paying past-due loans or leases or vendors is on hold for the time being. Unless you have a line of credit you can draw on or existing excess cash, you’ll be depending on existing clients and customers (or new ones) to keep bringing in enough revenue to keep going. That’s how turnaround guys stop the bleeding. Along the way, you’ll be laying off staff and cutting costs in any way you can. A turn-around professional can help you find other costs to cut. Turnaround experts have a lot of real-world experience to help them know where to cut. One part of this plan is the financial reporting for the business, starting from right now and including projections: balance sheet, income statement, cash flow.
Stage two of a turnaround comes later. Favorable results don’t come overnight, or even in a few weeks. The goal is to get enough time to get your short-term crisis under control so that you can then start focusing on long-term health. Several weeks after taking a fresh look at financials, sales, and future projections, it should become clear which direction things will be going. You’re either getting back to being cash flow positive (which means the core company can be saved) or you’re still shrinking. When you have cut your overhead to the lowest practical level, and you’ve figured out where your cash is coming from, then it’s time to start talking to your creditors.
The Most Important Creditors to Negotiate With
Contact the trade creditors and the bank at the same time, but the bank is first in line because it has a lien and can foreclose. You usually want to have your own attorney for negotiations, and a turnaround pro works directly with you. Any restructuring has to convince your trade creditors that they’ll get more with you in business than they would if you go under. Any deal with lenders has to convince them they’ll get more than they would from a foreclosure. Creditors don’t like surprises, so don’t surprise them.
What you don’t want to do is not tell the bank when you fall behind. You want to give the bank as much lead time as possible, which you won’t get if you wait to call the bank until the wire you promised last week finally arrives. Because banks really don’t want to seize collateral any more than anyone else wants them to. They’ll work with you when you’re honest, but a surprise overdraft gives them two bad choices: don’t renew, or trust that you’re not lying. If you lie once, they won’t trust you anymore. You may not want to tell the bank you’re behind because you worry that the bank will liquidate the collateral. Fear is the wrong reason not to call. To show the bank you mean business, you need a plan. The banker is more likely to believe the recovery plan when there’s already an independent turnaround professional on your team. Whatever kind of shape the plan is in, it has to be realistic. Bankers hate it when borrowers make promises they can’t keep. Bring your lawyers, and tell the banker beforehand. Expect the bank to have their lawyers there too. The meeting is to show the banker that you care about this, that you have a plan for doing something about it, and that you understand what the bank needs.
Bankers are more likely to be hard-headed than petty, but they can get emotional about things too. If they suspect that the owners have been siphoning funds out of the company, that can come up in the restructuring meeting. Best thing you can do is to offer the bank full access to all books and records. That way you disprove that suspicion at every turn.
What you’re asking the bank for ranges from waiving a covenant to total forbearance. It depends on whether you intend to keep operating, or liquidate instead. If the business is liquidating, expect the bank to want to know what the plan is for selling whatever assets they secured, how much it will cost to liquidate, and how the proceeds reach the bank. If your plan is to keep operating, ask the bank for a pause in principal payments, or else interest-only payments for a while. That keeps payments coming in at a slow but steady pace, and it’ll give you much-needed liquidity. A business with good employees in an honest management structure will almost always be given an opportunity to survive. Every case is different, of course.
The trade creditors usually can’t shut you down; they don’t have liens on your stuff, and they can’t seize anything from you the way a bank can. Sort your vendors into two piles: critical and not critical. The non-critical ones get a letter. Even a simple letter, on official company stationery, saying that the company is having difficulties, will buy you time. The purpose of the letter is to promise two things: first, that nobody will get paid anything at all until some other date in the future (at least 60 days), and second, that you will give everyone an update before that date. Attach whatever financials you have. The letter also should promise them a full report or a settlement offer before the standstill runs out. If they ask for cash on delivery, that’s understandable.
You should always call and tell your creditors where they stand. That’s good business practice. Many small businesses don’t do that very well, because they don’t have the extra staff. They don’t mean to, but they end up taking phone calls they can’t really answer, and the usual reactions are bad ones:
- Avoiding creditors by playing phone tag, which only makes everyone mad.
- Giving false promises that they don’t keep.
- Half-truths and misleading information.
Your vendors want the simple truth. Trade creditors are sometimes frustrated, but they’re also mostly reasonable. As long as you can answer their questions, they’ll probably go along with a standstill agreement to let you rebuild the business. Keep any vendors whose cooperation is essential up to date, or move them to COD. Other creditors include any equipment lessors. These can be the least reasonable creditors, but that doesn’t mean that they shouldn’t be approached. Bring them into the plan at the same time as your other vendors. Start by inviting the lessor to take back any equipment you no longer use. Pay for the equipment you still need. It’s reasonable to expect that they’ll be hard-headed, though. Often they just keep demanding payment. If there’s a creditor who keeps trying to collect while everything else stays frozen, they can push the business into bankruptcy.
With luck, the recovered business will be in position to get new financing from another lender and then can pay off the existing bank. Use your turnaround pro to pitch to other lenders: asset-based lenders, factors, equity investors. They’re typically used to taking on more risk than a bank will. A revised letter needs to go to the trade creditors. Give them two choices:
- A reduced percentage of what they’re owed immediately, if the cash is there.
- A larger percentage over time.
If they accept a reduced amount in return for quick payment, then that’s usually the smart choice for them. Not turned around yet? Ask your vendors to help you out a bit longer. You want your vendors to know when you are liquidating. Keep them posted regularly. If your plan has the liquidation sales finally starting to take in money, then it may be time to contact them with an offer to pay them something from the resulting proceeds. This has to go through the bank first, though, because the money from the sale will usually be part of what the bank secured.
Generally, if the principals are honest, everyone tends to get higher returns out of court instead of bankruptcy. If the business is doing an honest best effort, and if the owners aren’t keeping any secrets, then creditors usually will work with the business to help it survive. Open books, share financials early and often. It’s usually worthwhile to bring in an independent restructuring professional to keep the math above board and to review your assumptions with you. Bankruptcy can still happen, of course. For instance, if one trade creditor gets a judgment, that can drag you into bankruptcy.
Explain this to any creditor. It’s tempting to sue a troubled company, but that can drag the business into bankruptcy, where professional fees become yet another thing for the estate to pay for before creditors can recover any money. Even if one creditor wins its suit, it usually doesn’t get much more money this way, compared to its competitors. Legal fees usually eat that difference. In most cases, working with a struggling business that stays honest with you is better than putting them into bankruptcy, where everyone suffers. Don’t wait until it’s too late. Get help before the crisis happens, and be honest with your creditors. The results will speak for themselves.
Delancey Street
The only firm here that handles the full arc of a business debt file: attorney-led negotiation, ACH revocation, legal defense, UCC lien removal, and a settlement agreement with a real release attached. Over $100M settled, no upfront fees, all 50 states, settlements at 30-60% of the balance.
National Debt Relief
Not an MCA specialist. National Debt Relief does not negotiate advances, challenge confessions of judgment, or fight UCC liens. For the ordinary unsecured business debt sitting next to your advances, their scale and track record make them a reasonable option on that side of the ledger.
CuraDebt
Not an MCA specialist either. CuraDebt handles business debt alongside IRS and state tax resolution, so if unpaid payroll taxes have stacked up behind the advances, they can work that front while the MCA side is negotiated.
Not Sure Which of the Nine Fits Your File?
One call gets your agreements, your UCC index, and your cash position looked at by people who resolve business debt for a living, and you get told which of these nine is realistic and what it will cost. You pay nothing upfront, and that first read of the file is free.
Call for a Free ConsultationThis page is provided for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or professional advice. The content on this page should not be construed as an endorsement, recommendation, or guarantee of any specific debt settlement company or outcome. Individual results may vary based on the nature of the debt, creditor policies, and the specific circumstances of each case.
The rankings and evaluations presented reflect the independent editorial judgment of our review team based on publicly available information. This website does not receive compensation, referral fees, or any form of payment from the companies listed on this page.
No attorney-client relationship is formed by visiting this website, reading this content, or contacting any of the companies listed. Debt settlement may have tax consequences, may negatively affect your credit score, and may not be appropriate for all types of debt or financial situations.
Delancey Street is not a law firm. Delancey Street works with a nationwide network of attorneys and debt specialists who handle MCA defense, business debt settlement, and related services. Any attorney services referenced on this page are provided by independent, licensed attorneys within the Delancey Street network, not by Delancey Street directly.
Attorney Advertising. This page may be considered attorney advertising in some jurisdictions.