Understanding Federal Jurisdiction Over Criminal Cases – Attorney Explanation

Federal Jurisdiction Over Criminal Cases

Hey there! I know you’re probably wondering about how the federal government gets involved in criminal cases. I get it – it can be confusing trying to understand when the feds have jurisdiction versus the state. This article will break it all down for you in simple terms.

What is jurisdiction?

Jurisdiction basically means authority. It refers to a court’s power to hear a case and make decisions about it. There are two main types of jurisdiction in criminal law:

• Federal jurisdiction – authority of federal courts over federal crimes
• State jurisdiction – authority of state courts over state crimes

So if a crime violates federal law, it will be tried in federal court. If it violates state law, it will go through the state system. Seems pretty straightforward, right?

Examples of federal jurisdiction

There are a few main ways that federal courts can have jurisdiction over a criminal case:

1. Crime occurred on federal property
2. Crime violated federal law (like tax fraud or immigration offenses)
3. Crime involved federal interest (like terrorism or civil rights violations)
4. Crime crossed state lines (interstate drug trafficking)

Some examples:

• Robbing a post office – federal property
• Smuggling immigrants over the border – federal immigration law
• Bombing a government building – federal terrorism laws
• Kidnapping someone and driving them across multiple states – crossed state lines

There are lots of federal criminal laws that give federal courts jurisdiction. Common ones involve federal taxes, mail/wire fraud, civil rights, and drugs/weapons that cross state borders.

Examples of state jurisdiction

Most everyday street crimes fall under state laws and jurisdiction. Things like:

• Assault
• Robbery
• Rape
• Murder
• Burglary
• Car theft

Unless these crimes happen on federal property or involve a federal interest, states handle the cases. Each state has its own criminal laws and courts.

Concurrent jurisdiction

Sometimes a crime violates both federal and state laws. For example, someone might commit murder on federal land. This would give both the state and federal government jurisdiction to prosecute.

When this happens, it’s called “concurrent jurisdiction.” Usually the feds and state will work together to decide who will handle the case. Often the one who starts prosecuting first will keep it.

The downside is that defendants can potentially be tried for the same crime in both federal and state court. This doesn’t violate double jeopardy protections because they are considered separate “offenses.”

How are federal cases different?

There are some key differences in how federal criminal cases work compared to state cases:

• Federal cases begin with a grand jury deciding if there’s enough evidence to prosecute
• Burden of proof is on the prosecution – “guilty beyond reasonable doubt”
• Federal prosecutors are called U.S. Attorneys who work for the U.S. Department of Justice
• Trials take place in federal district courts in front of a federal judge
• Sentencing guidelines provide a framework but judges have discretion

The procedures and players are a bit different in the federal system. But the basics like trials, pleas, and sentencing still apply.

Why does it matter?

Understanding jurisdiction is important for a few reasons:

• Determines what laws apply and the potential penalties
• Decides what court system will handle the case
• Impacts the prosecutors, judges, and rules involved
• Affects the outcomes and consequences for defendants

Federal charges often bring harsher punishments and fewer opportunities for parole. But sometimes federal jurisdiction also provides more resources and flexibility.

The bottom line

Figuring out if a crime will be charged under federal or state laws can be complicated. There are lots of factors involved. But the basic thing to remember is federal courts handle federal crimes, and state courts handle state crimes.

Concurrent jurisdiction cases get tricky. But usually the feds and states coordinate to determine the best venue. The most serious crimes often end up going federal.

I hope this overview helped explain the difference between federal and state jurisdiction in criminal cases! Let me know if you have any other questions.

References