Can an MCA Funder Pursue Your Second Business? Six Entity and Asset Questions
Delancey Street offers an initial consultation about business debt and MCA concerns. The company is not a law firm; legal matters require independently licensed counsel. Services and eligibility depend on your circumstances and the written engagement.
Discuss Your Options: (888) 559-0156National Debt Relief
National Debt Relief describes services for eligible unsecured business obligations. Its published qualifications distinguish unsecured accounts from debts supported by collateral. Confirm that the particular account qualifies and ask what support is available if litigation begins.
CuraDebt
CuraDebt describes assistance with eligible business obligations, including some merchant cash advances. Its service disclosures explain that inquiries may be connected with independent providers or law firms. Establish who will perform the work and review that provider’s engagement, fees, and eligibility requirements.
Usually, an MCA funder can’t reach the second LLC unless one of these things happens:
- The second LLC signed a contract promising the funder it’d make good.
- The second LLC took on the old debts and substantially all of the first LLC’s assets.
- A court finds the LLCs were never really separate.
A lot of this is common sense. If the entities are truly separate, the LLCs will make their own agreements. A new LLC formed to do another advance after there’s trouble can be just what undoes the protection.
How this usually happens is that someone gets an advance from one fund provider. The first advance gets tight, so the business gets a second, stacked on top. Eventually, the third or fourth funder says no -- we’re out of room on this EIN. Then someone suggests a new LLC. The lender maxed out on the first company won’t fund it again. But the clean new company qualifies for a new advance. It seems like a smart workaround. Some people end up with six or more of these, all funded from one business.
The first question should be whether the second company ever contracted to pay up. Here it really does have to have signed. Of course, a security interest is a contract, and the filing only works to cover assets of an LLC that signed the agreement detailing what collateral would cover the funder’s loan. Signing the agreement for a loan with a lender is the part that gives the lender the authority to register collateral and list it on a financing statement. And the filing has to be under the entity’s exact legal name. A filing under a trade name alone isn’t enough. In New York, even if one LLC promises to stand behind another’s obligations, the guaranty is void unless written and signed by whoever’s held to the deal. The second LLC is a separate company. One LLC can’t agree for the other to pay.
The second question is about a different kind of claim. The new LLC may be on the hook if it took on the old LLC’s obligations as well as substantially all the old LLC’s assets. An LLC formed to do an MCA later isn’t in the same spot as one that carried on the business.
Pierce the Veil
The third question is trickier. The people running an LLC have to act as if it’s a separate company. Were the books kept separately, or were they held as one company? If two LLCs mix their business to the point they’re practically one, the creditor might argue they should be seen as one.
It is worth noting, however, that a court will not reach this result lightly. It will look at several factors before deciding, and then ask if the circumstances add up to a valid reason to pierce the veil. They may find the LLC was undercapitalized, that records weren’t kept separately, that the funds flowed between them.
To pierce the veil in New York and so hold one LLC liable for another’s obligations, the lender must show the owners controlled the company completely in the transaction at issue, and that they used that control to commit a fraud or wrong that injured the creditor. The state’s top court laid out this standard in the case of Matter of Morris v New York State Department of Taxation and Finance. A 2022 appeals court case looked at this test in the context of an LLC and refused to pierce though the trial court had found complete owner control and disregarded formality and undercapitalization.
Fourth, if the bank statements have expenses for the second LLC, the lender could ask if funds from the first LLC supported the new LLC. One way a creditor can learn about the payments between companies is from the evidence it requires before making an advance. They typically check bank activity for several months, so if a company routinely transfers between entities, the bank statements that won approval may show transfers between companies. This gives the funder’s lawyer leverage in settlement talks if they suspect commingling. They can ask for other entities’ financial statements and argue the second company’s revenue and assets should be available for payment of the debt.
A close look at how an entity moved money can expose a pattern of commingling.
- One checking account paying payroll, rent, and debt for several LLCs.
- The same person signs every MCA agreement as authorized officer for multiple companies, and it’s unclear which entity owes.
- Cash swept from one account to cover another entity’s daily debit to the funder.
- No separate books or tax filings for multiple entities.
- An entity formed only to qualify for funding.
Any one of these alone wouldn’t necessarily doom a veil defense. Small businesses do share resources. Yet the practice of juggling daily debits pushes you to move cash, building the very record the creditor’s attorney is hoping to find.
The fifth question is whether you signed any kind of personal guaranty. Since most MCA funding agreements already include a personal guarantee, your personal assets are vulnerable no matter how many LLCs were made to isolate liability. Veil piercing adds a second layer of exposure: the other LLCs’ receivables and accounts.
Sixth, did money or property move from the old LLC to the new LLC when it formed? New York voidable transactions law may give creditors four years, not six, to challenge those transfers.
Negotiate a Strategy
If money moved between entities, consider this as one problem with several fronts, rather than several problems. Be ready to negotiate a strategy that considers all your funding across all entities. Individual deals fall apart easily. Structured payment plans, lump-sum settlements, and even Subchapter V of Chapter 11 can help in serious cases. Which fits depends on how the entities were run.
Maintain Them as Individual Companies
Once you notice the commingling, undo it. Keep cash in the accounts that earned it, file taxes separately, and keep business receipts separate. Maintain them as individual companies. Yes, it is a lot of work. And it requires extra diligence to track the money. LLCs are used in this field to isolate liability. If companies start to bleed across the lines in the way of their assets and cash flow, the original point is lost.
A Consultation Begins With the Documents
Delancey Street offers a free initial review. Your agreements, payment records, and any court papers establish what needs attention.
Speak With Delancey StreetEditorial Disclosure and Legal Disclaimer. This article provides general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Delancey Street is a featured debt settlement company, not a law firm. Legal representation requires a separate engagement with licensed counsel. Creditor participation, savings, timing, and eligibility are not guaranteed. Settlement can affect credit and may have tax consequences. A consultation does not suspend court deadlines or create an attorney-client relationship.